CHAT about Coach finds/deals here!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hmmm.....I was sure the listing said walnut when I posted it. I wonder if the seller changed it? Of course, I could be mistaken. There is a pic of the walnut Lily in this thread, post #170.....http://forum.purseblog.com/coach/well-ladies-hell-froze-over-pigs-began-fly-398015-12.html

Oh, I beg your pardon...I thought everyone referred to this size as the XL.:shame:

Thanks. I stand corrected about the Walnut Lily - that it does exist. I do not see any revisions listed on the listing page.

TPFers call it the XL Lily but it really isn't XL. There was the medium and then this one which was just called the Lily Satchel. Then there is the carryon.

I was about to come and ask about the color of this Lily as well. The listing said "Whiskey" when i first saw it too (after ECJ posted it in the deals thread, thank you by the way!) but I think it's Walnut as well, since I have the Whiskey and mine definitely has more of a reddish appearance than this one does....
We shall soon see, I put in an offer last night, slept on it, and decided I couldn't let the opportunity to get the Walnut (hopefully!!) pass me by so I did a BIN on it.. Will post pics of the two side-by-side when I get it and let the experts make the call on the color!
I've been looking for the elusive Walnut color FOREVER...that and the Atlantic color that keeps taunting me (from the scammer seller)!
 
^I can verify just based on having Lily satchels in both sizes still NWT that the XL was indeed a designation to differentiate between the large and smaller size satchels, although in reality it is obvious based on the size, turnlock flap, lack of kisslock pocket on the medium, and price. Not sure where the XL designation originated from, though, as it's literally been all over the internet for years now, but I guess it could have started from the club thread here. I do know that when it's not listed that way on Ebay for the larger size, everyone asks which size! I've had a LOT of PMs over the years about the diff, lol! In any event, the tag does just read "Legacy leather Lily", $1200, for the "XL" as we define it here, and the smaller Lily tag reads "Legacy leather medium Lily", $768.

As for the bag in question, I also think it's probably walnut just based on the waxy appearance of the leather. Whiskey is generally more porous and has a totally different look and texture. There is actually a period of time where BOTH colors can look very similar despite the ultimate reddish appearance. I've had both pieces that nobody could ascertain the correct color (outside of the leather appearance IMO, which gave it away), but over time, the whiskey does redden more as it darkens. The walnut is more of a dark neutral brown. My bag is darker than this one at least based on photos, but that all depends on the environment and specific leather piece.

CONGRATS CA!!! I'm glad you were able to score one at a great price!!!
 
The stitching is less obvious to me, but it's probably my screen. That also may account for the color differences. I will have to view it later, but I'm also more or less certain it's walnut.
 
^I can verify just based on having Lily satchels in both sizes still NWT that the XL was indeed a designation to differentiate between the large and smaller size satchels, although in reality it is obvious based on the size, turnlock flap, lack of kisslock pocket on the medium, and price. Not sure where the XL designation originated from, though, as it's literally been all over the internet for years now, but I guess it could have started from the club thread here. I do know that when it's not listed that way on Ebay for the larger size, everyone asks which size! I've had a LOT of PMs over the years about the diff, lol! In any event, the tag does just read "Legacy leather Lily", $1200, for the "XL" as we define it here, and the smaller Lily tag reads "Legacy leather medium Lily", $768.

As for the bag in question, I also think it's probably walnut just based on the waxy appearance of the leather. Whiskey is generally more porous and has a totally different look and texture. There is actually a period of time where BOTH colors can look very similar despite the ultimate reddish appearance. I've had both pieces that nobody could ascertain the correct color (outside of the leather appearance IMO, which gave it away), but over time, the whiskey does redden more as it darkens. The walnut is more of a dark neutral brown. My bag is darker than this one at least based on photos, but that all depends on the environment and specific leather piece.

CONGRATS CA!!! I'm glad you were able to score one at a great price!!!

Thanks for seconding the color of this bag Baglady39....I'm very excited now. I do love my Whiskey Lily, but sometimes the color is just a little too red for me and I have a hard time matching her to my outfit. I was hoping the walnut would be a bit more neutral.
 
Thanks for seconding the color of this bag Baglady39....I'm very excited now. I do love my Whiskey Lily, but sometimes the color is just a little too red for me and I have a hard time matching her to my outfit. I was hoping the walnut would be a bit more neutral.


It is definitely more neutral! I find the scratches to be a PITA just because of the leather differences, but I agree. I like the whiskey leather but mostly prefer a brown with less red! I hope it turns out to be all you hope for and more!!
 
I was about to come and ask about the color of this Lily as well. The listing said "Whiskey" when i first saw it too (after ECJ posted it in the deals thread, thank you by the way!) but I think it's Walnut as well, since I have the Whiskey and mine definitely has more of a reddish appearance than this one does....
We shall soon see, I put in an offer last night, slept on it, and decided I couldn't let the opportunity to get the Walnut (hopefully!!) pass me by so I did a BIN on it.. Will post pics of the two side-by-side when I get it and let the experts make the call on the color!
I've been looking for the elusive Walnut color FOREVER...that and the Atlantic color that keeps taunting me (from the scammer seller)!
You're welcome!:cool:

Congratulations.....I can't wait to see pics!
 
Coach Poppy Oil Slick Boxy

Item condition: Pre-Owned
Price: $155.99 OBO
Shipping: FREE

http://www.bonanza.com/listings/Coach-Poppy-Oil-Slick-Boxy-Bag-EUC-RARE-/69895701

If only Coach would make a Sophia or Madison Shoulder Hobo in this color... the boxy is just a bit too small for me.

NMA

You may already know this, but Coach did make this in the Sabrina, but it retailed for $1000. Here's a link to a photo http://forum.purseblog.com/gucci/ssssshhhhh-we-wont-tell-anyone-about-your-non-526755-97.html it's in post #1451
 
Pretty good deal on the black Marielle 17067 (the larger one I believe?). Buy it now is $145 plus $6.99 shipping. I'm surprised no one has snatched it up yet. The pictures aren't great which may be why...but from her description, it doesn't sound as if the bag could be in too bad of shape.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Pre-Loved-C...517?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item4ab5f19d95
What terrible pictures! It amazes me when people just have pictures of parts of the bag and not one of the whole bag. If you aren't familiar with Coach styles, it would be impossible to see what this one looks like.
 
What terrible pictures! It amazes me when people just have pictures of parts of the bag and not one of the whole bag. If you aren't familiar with Coach styles, it would be impossible to see what this one looks like.

I agree...and that's probably the main reason it's not selling. The pic quality is pretty bad and like you said, there's not even a shot of the whole bag.
 
Top