It's a really tough choice. Personally, lookswise, I like the Chanel ones A LOT better. In fact, I'm in love with the CC earrings. They are super cute and can easily make any outfit chic. However, for that price, they won't even make them in silver. It's as if they want to squeeze every last penny out of the profit margin. Silver is already pretty cheap but they have to use Nickel. That aside, since my ears can take Nickel, I would still buy them BUT there have been so many problems with stones falling out and stuggles to get Chanel to replace them and I just don't want to have to deal with the headache of that. For those reasons alone, I would recommend Tiffanys.