Cartier or Rolex.....Which do you prefer??

[tdha]

I was all set to purchase the mid size ss tank when this rolex caught my eye, not to mention a gorgeous hermes cape cod which I may get in tan (no pics of that one, they wouldn't let me).. Ignore the bracelet, it is a medical alert and I have to wear it.

thoughts on either of these?? BTW I really appreciate your input!!!

 

[chessmont]

The Cartier! (this coming from someone who has 5 Rolexes, LOL!) It looks just stunning on you, the Rolex looks a little plain - though if it will just be for casual, I think the Rolex looks nice, too. I just don't think you can dress that one up, whereas the Cartier could go either way (IMO)

I guess what I mean it depends upon what you are going for, looks and use - wise.

 

[Classic Chic]

another vote for cartier, it's just more classic IMO, and i agree with chessmont, rolex do appears to be more casual than Tank's design

 

[laurayuki]

i like cartier better between the two

 

[ETenebris]

The Rolex is FABULOUS! Simple and elegant. The Cartier looks too busy and would be harder to read.

 

[everything posh]

I vote for the Cartier as well! It looks fantastic on you!!

 

[xi_captain]

Cartier!

 

[Jenna51580]

Cartier, however I normally like Cartier over rolex.

 

[claudette2]

Cartier, hands down.

 

[Monica]

The Cartier! I have this Cartier design as well and also a similar Rolex (with a yello face). The CArtier is really special and a classic. Rolex is a better watch maker IMHO and this model is sportive looking. I feel that with the Cartier it's easier to dress up and also great if you wear casual clothes.
Love your e-ring!!!

 

[butterfly36029]

Rolex...I really like it...it looks like the one my husband has and I love it I want it for me! The tank is classic and it looks nice but I'd rather have a Rolex

 

[Phillyfan]

I'm partial to rolex and vote for that one. Which model and size rolex are you wearing? The only Cartier I love is the roadster (which I have w/pink face).

 

[sbelle]

I think they both look great on you, but I am partial to the look of the Rolex--so that's what I'm voting for!

 

[Phillyfan]

ssc0619- Do you know which style and size rolex is pictured by OP of this thread? I know you know a lot about watches!

 

[tdha]

Thanks for the input.

The rolex is a date 34mm, white dial, index markers, oyster bracelet with smooth bezel. Personally I don't like fussy watches, this is the only rolex that has really appealed to me. I kept trying them on and it never felt right, so I changed to the TK, but then I saw this one today. I think I will end up with the tank though. This is my first luxury watch and I like its versatility. If I had other nice watches too, I would get the rolex.