I am team-snug and I prefer 17 to 18 on you.
Mine hardly passes my wrist bone, while I see that yours does (to me that may mean mine is more snug than yours maybe?). The most mine will sit on the protruding bone. But my love goes further down my arm when my hand is up, because I have a longer thinnest part of my hand.
I totally like this fit on me in 15. I don’t prefer how 16 fits.
Sharing these so that you have a reference snug fit can be comfy too. However, we don’t have 4 seasons here. I guess you may like to take summer sizing into your consideration.
I slept over this predicament for weeks before I exchanged my 16 to 15. Maybe you’ll need to sleep over it abit too
View attachment 5736827View attachment 5736828View attachment 5736829