I'm finding it so hard to believe that this could be a fake! I'm personally stumped... I'm definitely interested to see what others think of this now lol the smell factor is ODD though... I have purchased MK bags in saffiano leather where initially I couldn't smell the leather and with 2-3 uses I could smell it but it was never foul. I know its a rule to comment on the condition but the listing you initially provided said the bag was "new." Based on smell and scratches on the studs do you believe this? If you are not happy with it definitely return it.
The smell I believe will air out and the scratches are minor and on the back. I would be willing to live with them if the bag is real as I have been looking for this bag (with the silver hardware) for a long time and can't find it elsewhere. However, if it is fake, that is obviously a deal breaker.
The smell is not a leather smell but rather an artificial/chemical type smell. Again, this could have been from storage or shipment, not really sure about that.
I won't show publicly in this forum the mistake of the bag as there is a chance for the replicator learn from here and correct the mistake.
Sorry, but as I've seen the whole thing, I'm now sure that the bag is not authentic..
ElephanyGirl, please PM me if you want to know the mistake..The foul smelling raised the suspicion already..
Sadly, it's just too many replicas in the market, and I can say your bag is also in a very good details but how good the fakes, the mistake can still be spotted on the fakes