I don't want to step on any toes and my comments are in no way made with that intent but I've been lurking here for several months and noticed that in this AT forum more than others, listings are more apt to be deemed as fake or questionable when rather than the item being fake, the opinions are more based on pictures that are taken by non-photographers who don't know how to use the macro function and don't know the correct details to show.
With jewelry and charms, it's really difficult to get just the right focus, lighting, color, angles, etc. and because most ebay sellers aren't professional photographers, they both don't realize the importance of good clear pictures and also are unaware that their listings are being advised against, based solely on lousy pictures.
(Understand that I am well aware of the many fakes and I'm not condemning the reporting of those items, but I've also seem authentic items called fake based on details that lack of photography skills made look off.)
JMHO.