I think I like having a zipper. No one can just reach in my bag. That’s why I love the tilton as opposed to the xl Courtney or cooper hobo.
I don’t like when the top of the bag is in my armpit so I will definitely check the strap drop. I’m not to picky about the elbow test, just as long as the bag isn’t in my armpit I’m good. They did have a few twist strap hobos and I didn’t like the shoulder drop on it. It was smaller than I expected but it was A nice Looking bag.
Some of the bags will relax over time and the shoulder drop will get longer.
But that only happens if you use the bag and the leather softens. So, if shoulder
drop is important to you, I agree it's best to check it out and not compromise
in the hope that over time the bag will work for you. It's like buying tight shoes
and hoping they will stretch, or clothing that's too small hoping we will lose those
extra pounds and the pants will zip up! 😁
When you are in the store with all the bright lights and beautiful (hopefully) handbags
tempting you, it's hard to focus on all the potential handbag issues. It helps if
someone on the forum has posted their experience and you then have it fresh
in your mind. What works for one of us, or doesn't, may help someone else if we
share the reasons why we love/or don't love, a particular style/leather/feature/etc.
That's why this Dooney forum is so great, because posters take the time to
share more than yea or nay.