Both are so lovely, really the choice is up to you, it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks, as long as you love your choice. I like the first one better because it has the sun and moon dial and the smaller seconds dial, it is more detailed and the movement of the watch is more complex than the second one. As a watch collector, the first one really appeals to me more, but it's you who will be wearing it, so pick the one that you enjoy the most. BTW cute avatar pic!