Please help me choose! If you can only have one...

[designer307]

I vote for Classic.

 

[ocgirl]

Wow, I guess I'll be in the minority and vote for the classic. I'm really finicky, and every reissue I have seen (and maybe they were the floor model so therefore weren't in the best shape), there was a line on the bottom and the bag sagged. That I can even handle, but the top had that line too! They looked like paper that was folded flat in shipping, and the top was not rounded and curvy like the classic. That bothered me enough not to buy them. But this may be just my personal issue. LOL.

 

[butterfliie]

I vote for classic as well! I know Smooth will say reissue hands down so that kinda cancels my vote out

Although I do have my eye on the quilted faux-alligator fabric reissue for fall...

 

[PinkPudding]

I vote for classic too;p

 

[petals12]

Classic

 

[w-jade]

Buy both......LOL.....then pretend to your SO/PHH that they are the same bag..heehee

Sounds like a great idea! Jill, you're brilliant!

 

[anonymous]

reissue for sure!

 

[Kat]

classic flap in lambskin gets my vote

 

[mas2388]

Wow, I guess I'll be in the minority and vote for the classic. I'm really finicky, and every reissue I have seen (and maybe they were the floor model so therefore weren't in the best shape), there was a line on the bottom and the bag sagged. That I can even handle, but the top had that line too! They looked like paper that was folded flat in shipping, and the top was not rounded and curvy like the classic. That bothered me enough not to buy them. But this may be just my personal issue. LOL.

I understand what you're saying ocgirl! The reissue I saw definitely had a big crease on the bottom like it was laid flat and the top had a crease too. When the SA brought out a new reissue, it was completely matte and smooth!!! It was the most bizarre thing...

But it seems that most reissues have wrinkles and so I thought the smooth, matte one was a little strange. The SA told me that over time it would get wrinkly too...

If the classic flaps had the same wrinkles as the reissue I know it would drive me insane!

 

[pinkpiano]

reissue. 'coz you can always get the black classic

 

[katie123]

For me, classic flap looks prettier than reissue

I don't like that saggy bottom.

 

[chiaoapple]

wow, the poll numbers are close! I voted reissue, since the classic you really can get anytime.

 

[sailorgirl]

Buy both......LOL.....then pretend to your SO/PHH that they are the same bag..heehee

Jill, I think you are my long lost twin sister!!

 

[mas2388]

and they are neck and neck at 50% each!!!

I think I am slightly leaning towards the reissue since I can get the classic later...