Unfortunately if they're paying for a new one that usually is part of the deal, to relinquish the damaged one. I can't believe that happened though! I know, it is just an accident, but like, what are the chances that it'd have to be all over your beautiful bag?? Are there any other older colors you'd be interested in getting? Maybe one will pop up, ebay or wherever, in the near future? I just hope they don't make you rush in deciding what to do, they should give you ample time to look around and find a replacement. But I do think that since it is a much desired color and leather that you should be compensated as to the price it would be to replace the ice blue today... which would definitely be more than the current prices of weekenders. I dunno, guess I'm babbling. Lots of luck!