Sorry gals and don't hate me, but I don't think you should get either one! The cons are too definitive. Save your money and get something exactly perfect. If you don't, that's how you end up with a closet full of bags that you don't use, because, "well, this one is too tiny, and that one is too xxx..." So, sorry. You deserve perfection. Save your $$ and you'll be happier when you get exactly what you want!