Hey you! Hope you are well! I kept the Tote 22. I am not a fan of the Tabby clasp (the new messenger has a great clasp but not this one nor the redesigned 26). If you do get the Tabby, I would recommend an insert if you want the bag to maintain some structure as the denim is so soft (in a good way) that it will sag over time.T, did you end up keeping one? I was on Macy's site looking at skincare and decided to see what Coach they had. I'm not a silver hardware gal like you, but something about the black denim tabby with it and the saddle colored tags has me flirting with the idea of it.
Let me know what you decide (so many places have it, you may want to wait for a sale)...