I'm really not sure now. I thought the blues were the same "denim" color but the handles were just different. There was a mineral blue that was the first generation rogue but not in this doctor's satchel style - just regular rogue style. Maybe the handles being different give it a different look. I know I like mine because of the contrasting handles. Wish Coach made it so we could buy handles and interchange them on the bags! They really do make a difference in the look!
Your new Coach: a mini-reveal thread!
- Thread starter greenpixie
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
@pianolize congrats on the new pretties! I would love to see a mod shot with that Rogue Satchel. I find it funny that the Coach Outlet keeps emailing me about that particular bag and it has been sold out for a while now on the sale. It keeps saying "It is going fast! You better buy it!" LOL. Um can't!
No, and it sounds like you don't like them. I think they're fine and would go with everything, but you want to be excited about them. I'd exchange them for something that makes you instantly smile! Glance at one of your favorite bags/colors and see how you instantly light up. Then look at these and see how you feel. My favorite neutral is black, and I have a grey and chalk bags I like, but I like them more with a scarf or charm to color them. My favorites are colors though! Red, deep teals and bright blues and a little bright pink when I'm in the mood for it. (I want a bright sapphire or ultra violet!) Now that I have 2 turquoise bags, new ones will have to work to measure up!
Last edited:
They keep emailing me to hurry up and by my wishlist bags, but I wasn't invited to the sale. They're helping me get ready for a real ban.
Last edited:
Thanks so much for your input- I'm thinking they're perfect for dull winter doldrums-w-neutrals (I totally get your combo choices but have no camels/browns/those colors you've mentioned!)
I'm also thinking that now that it's sunny out, I'm thinking more vibrant.
Makeup cleansers! Great idea! I'm a huge fan of jeans+heels, as I rarely wear flats. So the color transfer from whatever just kills me.
So maybe they ARE the same- I'd actually wondered whether I could go get them attached @Coach house or something, since I'm trying to replicate that bag I can no longer get! Therefore, it looks "blank" to me. If I'm using it regularly ('not as a travel bag'), it feels 'missing'...
So true, so true! If they were easier to return, I think I would have by now. I'm sitting with them to see if it's just seasonal excitement for a color pop, after I'm getting over my initial surprise at the shades, though they really are beautiful and have nothing like them, color-wise.No, and it sounds like you don't like them. I think they're fine and would go with everything, but you want to be excited about them. I'd exchange them for something that makes you instantly smile! Glance at one of your favorite bags/colors and see how you instantly light up. Then look at these and see how you feel. My favorite neutral is black, and I have a grey and chalk bags I like, but I like them more with a scarf or charm to color them. My favorites are colors though! Red, deep teals and bright blues and a little bright pink when I'm in the mood for it. (I want a bright sapphire or ultra violet!) Now that I have 2 turquoise bags, new ones will have to work to measure up!
Haha, good!!! WHY do they do that?!They keep emailing me to hurry up and by my wishlist bags, but I wasn't invited to the sale. They're helping me get ready for a real ban.

Last edited:
Very pretty! Congrats! [emoji255]View attachment 3998073
My newest acquisitions!
The bags themselves are gorgeous; the colors are 'odd' in my wardrobe by just a bit, so not 100% sold on them...
These are great colors, @pianolize! The dark denim is a perfect neutral. I think it would go great with black/grey and would tone down a lot of crazy colors. I would pair it with pinks, yellows, greens, and orange, as well as whites and beiges. The mineral you mention is rather similar in tone and it was really more of a dark teal. At least the mineral Rogue I have.Thanks both!!! @tealocean , the rogue is 'dark denim/old brass', and the Faye is 'antique rose/gold'? I'll try to get the color on the photo better- they're both truly beautiful, but I was hoping/remembering a darker, deeper blue (mineral?!); and a pinker 'rose'.
They really are freestanding, 'neutral' colors- but since I either wear blacks OR a crazy color, they'd clash OR I'd pick a more vibrant or metallic color to offset the blacks/grays!!! Or go straight black. (@carterazo & @Sparkletastic , I feel I need to ask your thoughts on this!!!)
Thinking back of the first (stock) picture you posted of the Faye when you bought it, I know it's a delightful rose color. I love it! [emoji7] I think it's a perfect pink for black and greys. The contrast is not too harsh imo. It would be delicious paired with a black and white outfit. It's a deep rose without being too bright, or too dark. Don't you think? This pink can be dressed up or down too. I love the contrast of the three types of leather as well. But you have to love it so that you can enjoy it. [emoji4] [emoji173] If you don't love the colors, don't let our excitement sway you. [emoji56]
Can you post other pics in a different light?
Last edited:
They keep emailing me to hurry up and by my wishlist bags, but I wasn't invited to the sale. They're helping me get ready for a real ban.
This is too funny! Gotta love Coach!
thanks, @carterazo !
The pinks with the suede I just love!!! I think you're totally right, since when ordering I was on a black/white kick.
About the satchel-
I THINK I SHOULD HAVE gotten the dk teal-ish mineral?/snake handled satchel when I first saw it. This one seems lighter and not as stunningly gorgeous as the original I'd wanted. And smaller than the travel bag I'd envisioned. Maybe I should take the wrapping off and walk around with it. (And look up the returns! I'm feeling like IF I can find the other in a comparable price , though it's skyrocketed, I'll buy/return. Haven't been able to though-it just doesn't seem available...)
@Sparkletastic would you come over and put outfits together for me!! Lol. You gave me some good ideas!
One of these days I’m going to put outfits together and take pictures. At 5:30 in the morning I’m a little too lazy to try and ‘style’ outfits! There’s an app for this too but I can’t remember what it’s called
View attachment 3998073
My newest acquisitions!
The bags themselves are gorgeous; the colors are 'odd' in my wardrobe by just a bit, so not 100% sold on them...
Love your bags! I think the blue is a great option for a neutral besides black!
Here’s my newest. I wanted a tote in pink. I was looking at the Market Tote, which is a similar design as an LV Neverfull, but wasn’t sure if I would like a bag with little organization and no zipper.
Then I see this in Macys and it is a bit basic (to me anyway), but checked off all my requirements!
It’s super comfortable, lightweight and the leather is yummy!!
Taylor Tote in Dusty Rose and her Unicorn charm
Then I see this in Macys and it is a bit basic (to me anyway), but checked off all my requirements!
It’s super comfortable, lightweight and the leather is yummy!!
Taylor Tote in Dusty Rose and her Unicorn charm
Both of my bags arrived, it’s love for both of them. I love anything with crystals
It sounds like you should search for the one you truly love. Hopefully you find it in time to return this other one. Good luck!