Sorry I´m baaad at authenticating, but to me it looks good. That´s why I only look at stuff from reputable sellers. Maybe try pm´ing vintage lovers if they could take a look since not everyone visits the autheticate this thread. Here´s a vintage Kelly from a reputable sellers in Switzerland for example http://www.luxury-shops.com/1_search/detail.php?ID=7902&category=&subcat=&designer==I found another one, this one shows less usage, http://forum.purseblog.com/hermes-shopping/authenticate-this-hermes-17673-729.html#post4499555
perhaps this would be a better choice, it's about $1700. It's a dark blue Kelly but it looks better than the black one... opinions?