Why did designers stop making Kelly-style bags?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

There are hundreds around at the moment and at almost every pricepoint! Good time to buy one.

All current, all Kelly-style (from the top of my head so check spellings)

Gucci (leather handles)
Sylvie;
Padlock;
Queen Margret
Broche;

Gucci (bamboo handle)
Ottilia;
BTH;
Moth TH;
Frame Print;
Broche;
Lilith;
Queen Margret

Celine
New Frame

Hermes
Kelly

Launer
Traviata
Juliet
Maggie
Royale
Rosina
Encore
Adagio
Diva
Nocturne

Delvaux
Brilliant
Tempete

Chanel
Coco handle

Mansur Gavriel
Elegant
Metropolitan

Asprey
167
Belle

Etc
 
Chanel has the Coco Handle and LV has the Croisette and One-handle Bag, those are just 2 that come immediately to mind. i actually collect kelly/top-handles b/c they are a more vintage look. they are considered old-fashioned and ladylike, and many of the vintage ones are quite small b/c women carried significantly less in the 50s and early 60s when these were hugely popular. they were typically paired with gloves and pillbox hats and carried to work at an office or out for a date. bag styles kind of correspond to women as a whole, right? now that women work and have more stuff to do and carry they can't really be out with these tiny handheld bags... for efficiency and ease of lifestyle the crossbody has become the main, followed by totes. the handheld kelly's represent something old-fashioned and lots of modern women don't want to look 'old,' so they avoid these styles, as do many designers. it's a classic style though and it'll always be around in some form.
 
There are hundreds around at the moment and at almost every pricepoint! Good time to buy one.

All current, all Kelly-style (from the top of my head so check spellings)

Gucci (leather handles)
Sylvie;
Padlock;
Queen Margret
Broche;

Gucci (bamboo handle)
Ottilia;
BTH;
Moth TH;
Frame Print;
Broche;
Lilith;
Queen Margret

Celine
New Frame

Hermes
Kelly

Launer
Traviata
Juliet
Maggie
Royale
Rosina
Encore
Adagio
Diva
Nocturne

Delvaux
Brilliant
Tempete

Chanel
Coco handle

Mansur Gavriel
Elegant
Metropolitan

Asprey
167
Belle

Etc

What do you think of Pickette London? And this Italian brand Cellerini? I am eyeing these 2 brands. Thanks!
 
The newer styles come with detachable straps and "bigger" or have modern fun designs. Imo coco handle is in a different category because of its size?

The styles you've described would've been perfect for evening/more formal occasions back in the days but now they're competing with other bags with more space as people are more casual. Eg I know a lot of the mums stop using these bags and opt for bigger bags like neverfull, and carry something way casual and less structured like Gucci disco/woc crossbody if they really need to have another bag.

I'm currently look to buy Gucci bamboo top handle which itself is iconic style, but definitely in the same category? Needless to say I'm a fan of Kelly too.
 
Top