Which would you choose?

[NikNak11]

My husband is buying me a present in honor of a long road to giving birth to our second daughter. I have been obsessed with the Tiffany Yellow Bezet ring and got my hands on a .22 fancy vivid IF. I also looked at the new Infinity ring and can't decide between the two. The infinity looks better overall and has great presence but I know I'll never have another chance at a yellow diamond in this price point (I guess there are only 5 in America right now.). Thoughts? The white gold band in pic is my own. Which of the two or try for something different in similar price range (like diamond olive leaf ring)?

 

[lexus72]

Congrats on your new addition! I love the infinity ring, but the Yellow Diamond is so rare and beautiful. I feel you can find an infinity in the future! My vote is for the Yellow Bezel! IT IS BEAUTIFUL!!!

 

[NikNak11]

Thanks! I guess I'm slightly worried if it's the correct proportion with my hand or if it looks too small. More pics:

 

[lovieluvslux]

Hard choice. I feel the yellow diamond ring is a bit small on your hand, but still pretty.

 

[Shopgirl1996]

Congrats on the birth of your 2nd daughter!

I really like the infinity ring on your hand. It looks great. The vivid yellow diamond ring (though beautiful) looks a bit small. If it's in budget, maybe you could get them to alter the setting for you to make it into a halo (if you like that design)?

Good luck with your choice!

 

[lexus72]

I see what you mean. I think it does look a bit small. The eternity ring looks like it belongs on your finger! either choice is a win win! I do think you might second guess yourself if you go with the Yellow diamond, just putting my 2cents in.

 

[NikNak11]

I can't decide if the yellow being small is a good thing because it makes it more wearable for every day- or if it just looks awkward.

 

[Christofle]

The infinity ring is very elegant. It has a bit more presence whereas the yellow diamond while lovely, disappears on your hand.

 

[AntiqueShopper]

I would go for the Bezet.; I would ask if they had any with a lower clarity and a larger carat weight in your price range or if they anticipate getting some in within the next few months. This way you can get the stone you want with a larger presence.

 

[MatAllston]

I vote for the bezet because it's more rare and it's so beautiful on your finger. The infinity will be around and you can get that down the road.

 

[emchhardy]

I prefer the infinity - much more presence.

 

[staceyjan]

I vote for the infinity. The yellow diamond is beautiful but a little too small.

 

[Louish]

Hmmmm I was going to say the yellow diamond since it's so rare but it kinda gets lost on your hand (& that's coming from someone with a teeeny engagement ring!). I'm not a big fan of the infinity ring either. Is it a loose yellow diamond? Can it be set in a different setting which has more presence? For sentimental reasons I like the idea of a rare & unique diamond to celebrate the birth of your unique and beautiful daughter

 

[dell]

I agree with the above post. Can the diamond be set into another setting? I'm not a fan of halos, but that would look amazing and really pop in a white gold setting with a white diamond halo!

 

[ArielNature]

I really like the yellow diamond but I wonder if you can get it in another setting. If not, the infinity looks gorgeous as well! Your pictures helped a lot, I think for your size of hand, the infinity looks stunning. (They both do!)