CMM - The IF was for the Channel ring. The split-shank Lucida was a VS1. Do you have pictures posted of your ring and what are the specs? Would love to see!
You know, I get the whole "substantial" thing. My first ering was really substantial (I'm talking metal, not diamond) and and I could "feel" it, KWIM? My current ering is very delicate, which I really enjoy now but took some time getting used to.