Which piece is more special? (Tiffany vs VCA)

[BigAkoya]

You know... I agree. The butterfly is beyond beautiful, and I wouldn’t regret buying it. But a bracelet would get so much more use, and I think people would appreciate the “value” more

I know you're asking for opinions, but you made a couple of comments such as "people don't like the butterfly" and "people will appreciate the value more."

In the end, our opinions don't matter. You should buy what you love. Only a very small percentage of people even know what VCA is. My guess is no one will recognize the Tiffany bracelet because it is not iconic, so don't be disappointed if folks don't say "wow, look at your $30K bracelet". Most will probably think it costs just a thousand or two. My gut feel says you love the butterfly the most, so go for it. Forget what others think, including me. Jewelry is for you to love.

 

[eternallove4bag]

Posted this in the Tiffany forum, where people seemed to like the enchant bracelet more. Curious to see if this forum’s members will think the same.

I’m debating between three pieces. Feel free to choose more than one option if you’re also conflicted

1. VCA perlee clover bangle
2. Tiffany enchant flower bracelet
2. Tiffany high jewelry butterfly brooch

View attachment 4988006

View attachment 4988007

View attachment 4988008

I may be a little biased but I voted for the perlee clover bracelet. It’s special and yet at the same time so easy to wear! It’s my HG piece of jewelry for a reason. I am also a fan of more structured/solid bracelets.

 

[mikimoto007]

Without a doubt, the Tiffany butterfly is the most special piece. I've never seen another like it. It may not be to my taste, and I would have no idea how to wear it, but it's definitely beautiful and special.

The enchant bracelet is a little cutesy to me, but it may have an entirely different presence in real life.

The perlee clover is the gorgeous, and probably the most wearable in my opinion.

 

[etoupebirkin]

OP,
The RealReal has the exact same Tiffany Enchant bracelet up for sale for $14,995. I am on the early bird list. we can see listings 24 hours prior to it going up on the site. If you are interested, I’d grab it.

I did not consign the bracelet, FYI.

 

[sosauce]

OP,
The RealReal has the exact same Tiffany Enchant bracelet up for sale for $14,995. I am on the early bird list. we can see listings 24 hours prior to it going up on the site. If you are interested, I’d grab it.

I did not consign the bracelet, FYI.

Oh, very interesting. Not an easy piece to come across, so this is kind of fortuitous timing. Since the herbal consensus seems to be diamond bracelet, I requested three from my SA.

The enchant flower bracelet, the Victoria alternating bracelet, and the Victoria mixed cluster bracelet. They should arrive sometime this week, so I can take mod shots

 

[sosauce]

Oh, very interesting. Not an easy piece to come across, so this is kind of fortuitous timing. Since the consensus seems to be a diamond bracelet, I requested three from my SA.

The enchant flower bracelet, the Victoria alternating bracelet, and the Victoria mixed cluster bracelet. They should arrive sometime this week, so I can take mod shots

And now on this thread, it’s shifted to the bangle. Lol

 

[glamourbag]

I think the best advice is to follow your heart on a purchase like this. Try the bracelets on (I know you cannot try on the brooch as it's a special order) but at least between the two bracelets, you will know. It is great to ask our advice and opinions and to take their value, but when it really comes down to it, you need to follow your heart. A piece that speaks to you the most will bring the most happiness. If you don't follow your heart, and go with what is most popular just because its popular in the poll, you will always be wanting what really calls you. Jewellery isn't a bag or a pair of shoes; its a very personal thing so my advice is to get what makes you gasp when you try it on; anything less isn't really worth it. If you know it is the brooch when you think of it, then it is the one. All three are stunning pieces and whichever you choose will be a remarkable addition to your collection. Good luck!

 

[etoupebirkin]

Well, the bracelet on TheRealReal sold. I hope the OP grabbed it. It was a fantastic price and returnable. Normally, Tiffany pieces on TRR average 2/3rds of retail, this was more than half off.

 

[sosauce]

Well, the bracelet on TheRealReal sold. I hope the OP grabbed it. It was a fantastic price and returnable. Normally, Tiffany pieces on TRR average 2/3rds of retail, this was more than half off.

Omg nooo I missed out I literally didn’t think it would sell within 2 days. Like... shocked. I wanted to try the enchant bracelet in the store and take modeling pics before purchasing.

It’s okay though. I was prepared to spend more at a later time of year... It’ll be a special purchase anyway and my SA would appreciate the sale, so...

 

[etoupebirkin]

Omg nooo I missed out I literally didn’t think it would sell within 2 days. Like... shocked. I wanted to try the enchant bracelet in the store and take modeling pics before purchasing.

It’s okay though. I was prepared to spend more at a later time of year... It’ll be a special purchase anyway and my SA would appreciate the sale, so...

I would keep an eye on it anyway in case the buyer returns the item. You never know.
FWIW, I did not think it would go that quickly either.

 

[DS2006]

Oh, at that price, I thought that bracelet would be gone immediately. I'll admit to having been tempted but did not pursue it. If it was in excellent condition, that was a fantastic deal. Someone was a very lucky buyer! Congrats if it is someone here!

On another note, most VCA is priced so close to retail on resale sites that I can't see why anyone would buy second hand just to save 5% or less on currently available pieces.

 

[sosauce]

Oh, at that price, I thought that bracelet would be gone immediately. I'll admit to having been tempted but did not pursue it. If it was in excellent condition, that was a fantastic deal. Someone was a very lucky buyer! Congrats if it is someone here!

On another note, most VCA is priced so close to retail on resale sites that I can't see why anyone would buy second hand just to save 5% or less on currently available pieces.

Omg, yeah, I totally agree with that. The price is always so close to retail for VCA secondhand. I really don’t understand. Especially because a lot of sellers will say, “No refunds or exchanges. Final sale only.”

Like, for me, at least you have the option of store credit (or a refund at Neiman) if you don’t end up loving the piece. Also, you get all the fun perks of customer service and hospitality, and a lovely sales environment

 

[DS2006]

Omg, yeah, I totally agree with that. The price is always so close to retail for VCA secondhand. I really don’t understand. Especially because a lot of sellers will say, “No refunds or exchanges. Final sale only.”

Like, for me, at least you have the option of store credit (or a refund at Neiman) if you don’t end up loving the piece. Also, you get all the fun perks of customer service and hospitality, and a lovely sales environment

That is absolutely true that the shopping experience is added value! Totally agree about exchange or return, as well.

 

[sosauce]

So, I don’t like the mixed Victoria bracelet. I’ve crossed that off my list. It’s also $7,000 more for only 0.25 more carats of diamonds, which I find crazy.

Per the suggestions I saw here, I looked into the Victoria alternating bracelet. And it’s so stunning! I’m so surprised. I thought the design was too cookie cutter, but I actually like it, too.

Honestly, I think a diamond bracelet is the way to go. Making my heart sing much more than the perlee clover, if I’m being honest.

Still, between the enchant flower bracelet and the Victoria alternating bracelet, it’s hard to decide. Personally, I find the enchant to be so intricate with the beading and the textured rose-cut diamonds. But the Victoria is so iconic, and it might pair better with Alhambra. Also, perhaps it has greater longevity.

 

[lovieluvslux]

I voted for VCA as I would pick that bracelet. However, "more special" is in unique would be the Tiffany butterfly brooch. I am more likely to wear the bracelet over the brooch.