Which piece is more special? (Tiffany vs VCA)

Which piece is more special?

  • VCA perlee clover bangle

    Votes: 71 54.6%

  • Tiffany enchant flower bracelet

    Votes: 61 46.9%

  • Tiffany butterfly brooch

    Votes: 7 5.4%
  • Total voters
    130

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

sosauce

sosauce

Member
Jan 27, 2021
415
2,981
#1
Posted this in the Tiffany forum, where people seemed to like the enchant bracelet more. Curious to see if this forum’s members will think the same.

I’m debating between three pieces. Feel free to choose more than one option if you’re also conflicted

1. VCA perlee clover bangle
2. Tiffany enchant flower bracelet
2. Tiffany high jewelry butterfly brooch

D2F11D89-65FE-493B-A911-8832E7B2488F.jpeg

CEA1A73F-966D-486D-822D-FC3A88355CDD.jpeg

623DF185-980D-4B6F-8BE7-C89425817719.jpeg
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 880, oranGetRee and hhw
Shop Van Cleef & Arpels at Fashionphile
#2
Hi! Of all three, I think the Tiffany Enchanted is more unique although I am not a fan of rose cut diamonds (they seem too soft for me). The VCA Clover, while iconic, is actually a very simple bangle. I'm not a fan of the butterfly, but that's just me.

That said, my favorite diamond bracelet from Tiffany is the Victoria alternating bracelet. It's a classic tennis bracelet, but with the alternating Xs and Os, it is just beautiful. Have you tried it on? There are a couple of sizes, but if you are looking at the Tiffany Enchanted bracelet, the larger Victoria alternating is similar in price point and would really pop. You can also get the matching earrings (size medium to me is the best).

Here is the bracelet I am referring to:
Tiffany Victoria® Cluster Tennis Bracelet in Platinum with Diamonds | Tiffany & Co.

Good luck to you! You have a nice budget, so you can really go to town choosing your special piece!
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 880, oranGetRee, Rhl2987 and 4 others
#3
I have to agree with @BigAkoya, no to the brooch. Yes to the 2 bracelets and the Tiffany looks more special in these photos, since it is more unique and can be worn day or special occasion. However, very different purposes between the 2 bracelets, so it depends on what you are looking for.

I also love the Victoria line from Tiffany, it’s a classic line that’s been around forever, and never comes and go with fashion. It is classic, chic, and simple, while stunning.

How does this Tiffany bracelet look when on the wrist because this looks like a side angle? Any way to post modeling shots of both? Good luck, a fun and blessed predicament to be in :)
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 880, sosauce, J_love_Chanel and 5 others
#5
I love both the Perlee Clover bangle and the Tiffany Enchant bracelet! They are totally different, though! I see the Enchant bracelet as being very dressy...I'd almost never have the chance to wear it. Whereas, I think the Perlee Clover bangle can be worn with nice casual attire. The Enchant bracelet is gorgeous, though. That line is one of the few I like at Tiffany.

To me, the Tiffany Enchant Scroll bangle is more comparable to the Perlee Clover.

Bracelets for Women | Tiffany & Co. US

Explore classic and modern Tiffany bracelets for every occasion. Discover diamond bracelets, charm bracelets and stackable bangles in silver and 18k gold.
www.tiffany.com www.tiffany.com
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: wisconsin, 880, sosauce and 3 others
#8
So I went to the Tiffany website and OMG the modeling picture of the Enchant bracelet is AMAZING!!!!! Don’t think about it for one more second. There is no comparison for the work of art and femininity and delicateness of the Tiffany bracelet with the Perlee Clover. Don’t get me wrong, the Perlee Clover is beautiful and I LOVE it, but that Tiffany bracelet is in a different league, and frankly you are getting much more than you are at the respective price points, since let’s be honest the diamonds in all regular-VCA pieces are tiny.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: wisconsin, 880 and sosauce
#9
I agree that both bracelets are beautiful and are very different. If speaking strictly of diamonds, the Enchant is a lovely design and you can really appreciate the delicacy and beauty of the stones. IMHO, the clover, which I'm not totally sold on FOR ME, (although stunning on others) is a piece that has more presence and is bolder, which I notice when viewed from a distance. The Enchant definitely looks more dressy to me. The clover perlee can be worn for dressy occasions or casually everyday. Just my thoughts... So for me, based on cost per wear, the perlee is more special. However, every defines "special" differently.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 880, sosauce and DS2006
#12
BigAkoya said:
Hi! Of all three, I think the Tiffany Enchanted is more unique although I am not a fan of rose cut diamonds (they seem too soft for me). The VCA Clover, while iconic, is actually a very simple bangle. I'm not a fan of the butterfly, but that's just me.

That said, my favorite diamond bracelet from Tiffany is the Victoria alternating bracelet. It's a classic tennis bracelet, but with the alternating Xs and Os, it is just beautiful. Have you tried it on? There are a couple of sizes, but if you are looking at the Tiffany Enchanted bracelet, the larger Victoria alternating is similar in price point and would really pop. You can also get the matching earrings (size medium to me is the best).

Here is the bracelet I am referring to:
Tiffany Victoria® Cluster Tennis Bracelet in Platinum with Diamonds | Tiffany & Co.

Good luck to you! You have a nice budget, so you can really go to town choosing your special piece!
Click to expand...

Well, it seems that I now know to get a bracelet, since people don’t seem to like the brooch, ahahaha.

I’ll have to request the enchant bracelet so I can model. I love the enchant because of the flowers. I like the Victoria, too, especially the mixed cluster (which doesn’t seem to be popular). I’ll ask my SA to bring the three bracelets in so I can take some photos.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 880, Cool Breeze and marbella8
#13
marbella8 said:
I have to agree with @BigAkoya, no to the brooch. Yes to the 2 bracelets and the Tiffany looks more special in these photos, since it is more unique and can be worn day or special occasion. However, very different purposes between the 2 bracelets, so it depends on what you are looking for.

I also love the Victoria line from Tiffany, it’s a classic line that’s been around forever, and never comes and go with fashion. It is classic, chic, and simple, while stunning.

How does this Tiffany bracelet look when on the wrist because this looks like a side angle? Any way to post modeling shots of both? Good luck, a fun and blessed predicament to be in :)
Click to expand...

I have to try it on, ahaha. I’ve never seen the enchant in person before. But I’ve always loved how it looks online. So delicate and natural. The beaded setting surrounding each stone. It’s just so... ~intricate~
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: 880 and marbella8
#14
innerpeace85 said:
I love love VCA but in this case I voted for Tiffany enchant flower bracelet. It is stunning!! Also understated without the clover motif
Click to expand...

I love VCA too! I think the enchant honestly looks like it could be a VCA piece. Reminds me of the folie des pres bracelet.

I think the enchant’s beaded borders surrounding the stones make it look very similar to VCA and also make it pretty stackable with other pieces from VCA
 
  • Love
Reactions: 880
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top