That is no ordinary boy! Love the chain details on it. It will probably not repeat in this exact combo. The fact that it's old medium and caviar is just icing on the cake. Definitely the more practical choice. The mini top handle is much more delicate and holds much less in comparison.
At the end of the day, buy what your hearts feels, not what is harder to get. With the constant repeat of caramel color and top handle minis every other season, I feel like it may come around again. I'd say get that special boy!