Which Garnet Ring for Everyday?

[aarti]

i don't know how comfortable i would be buying gems from etsy because I have no experience in doing so but i really think the macys is classic

 

[evekitti]

Happy 30th!!

Another vote for Macys.

 

[thaithai]

Thanks for your help all!! I ordered the one from Macy's (one in the store was too small) and it should be here in about a week. Will post pics when it arrives!

 

[lordguinny]

Macys hands down!

 

[narcissistmas]

I personally love the Macy's one. I think it makes more of a statement than the other. Plus I kinna don't like when the stone doesn't extend the band.

 

[randr21]

macy's one for sure