Which earrings would you rather....?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Junkenpo

Junkenpo

Maui Strong...♥️
O.G.
Jan 23, 2007
9,834
4,235
#1
get?

I'm considering purchasing diamond studs...and I'm not sure what to go with. I know people don't scrutinize your ears nearly as much as the ones on your finger... and you don't see earrings while you're wearing them.


Sooo... .50ctw round, I color, SI1 clarity, ideal cut

or

....... .75ctw princess, I color, SI2 clarity, good cut

Price for either is almost the same... so i'm really debating on whether size or cut makes more of a difference to me at this point...

Opinions?
Smaller earrings that are possibly sparklier, or larger earrings that would still be sparkly, but maybe not as?
 
#2
I have 1cttw princess studs, don't know the rest of the specs as they were a gift. My stepmom has what look like .8 cttw round cut studs. They are SO sparkly I can't stop staring at them when she's talking. My princess studs catch the light, but they don't sparkle nonstop the way hers do. I know it's a sign that the quality is not as good, but I prefer it because they are more subtle, but still classic, beautiful diamonds, you know?
 
#6
I have both round and princess cut diamond earrings and honestly LOVE the princess cut ones... I rarely wear the rounds anymore... in fact, can't remember the last time I did.
 
#8
I would always buy the ideal cut stones. I have a pair & my decorator told me she looked out her office window to see if I had arrived & she said she saw my earring sparkle! And she's on the second floor! I just laughed at her but maybe the sun was just right. Anyway they are worth the price. Sacrifice clarity & color & always buy ideal cut.
 
#10
thanks ladies! my gut was telling me that i should go ideal cut.. quality over quantity, right? LOL

I just spent the last hour stewing over the decision, bc these are actually a belated bday gift for my mommy. If it was me, i'd go for the smaller earrings, but my mom is one of those people who never buys anything really nice for themselves.... so i wanted to get her something a little more substantial.

I wound up staying with round (i was having trouble picturing princesses on her ears), doubling up on the carat size (.92ctw) and keeping the ideal cut... it kinda doubled the price, but i figure she's worth it, and i can always borrow them if i wanna get fancy. ;)

I'll make sure to take modeling pics of her ears when she gets them!

thanks for your help!:tup:
 
#13
I love both. I have a .50 set of princess cut.. that I love.

But round is much more classic form.

I am torn though. since they are the same price.. and yet about 25 points more.

I dont think the clarity radius will make one sparkly then the other.. because its so close.

a princess is cut different.. and has a flat top.. so it may appear not as sparkly...

Ooh I am no help. I would have to see them...lol

I still think round is more Classic.
 
#14
Junkenpo said:
thanks ladies! my gut was telling me that i should go ideal cut.. quality over quantity, right? LOL

I just spent the last hour stewing over the decision, bc these are actually a belated bday gift for my mommy. If it was me, i'd go for the smaller earrings, but my mom is one of those people who never buys anything really nice for themselves.... so i wanted to get her something a little more substantial.

I wound up staying with round (i was having trouble picturing princesses on her ears), doubling up on the carat size (.92ctw) and keeping the ideal cut... it kinda doubled the price, but i figure she's worth it, and i can always borrow them if i wanna get fancy. ;)

I'll make sure to take modeling pics of her ears when she gets them!

thanks for your help!:tup:
Click to expand...

I'm sorry I missed this.. when I just posted. Glad you went with round. I am sure she will love them. You are such a wonderful daughter.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top