Well, my DH is getting me the one on the right 2.34 antique J SI1 platinum setting, for our 10 Year anniversary (and I am only 31!). I am just debating on keeping the original setting or changing it to a halo...And yes this one is coming from EricaD! Either ring will be matched with a eternity band. Thanks for all the input ladies it helps to hear things I may not have thought of myself and keep voting! I will post pics of my acquisition.