Ah thanks for your input. I never tested how much the Page holds. I already have a dinky in dusty rose color. So I probably have to rexonsider about the PageI am not a fan of the Page, not because of size exactly, it is how it is oriented and the flap on the top. I feel like it is hard to get things in and out of it because it is deeper and not wide. I much prefer the Dinky because it is wider. I would say that the Page can hold about the same if not a little more than the Dinky 24. The flap on the top was my deal breaker, it was just awkward trying to get into the bag. Normally flaps (like on the Dinky or Saddles) don't bother me.
If you don't want to get another Rogue then get the saddle. That Rogue is really pretty though! And I love Rogues.