which bag should I get

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

chenyinshanyi

chenyinshanyi

Member
Sep 10, 2017
15
8
#1
recently I start to get obsessed with Coach 1941 line and tea rose stuff. I sold one LV trevi bag and a Valentino camera pouch bag to get more Coach bags since I love Coach's design way much more.
I bought a grey rogue 25 with tea rose, a white parker with tea rose and a dusty-rose-pink dinky with rivets.
I am still considering to get the below items, and want to hear your opinion which one I should get?
I really like the old vintage mustard yellow color Coach has in their 1941 line. So I am deciding between the Saddle and the Rogue 25?
rogue 25:
22797_bplqd_a0

Saddle:
image.jpg

Also I am thinking to get the black Page with snakeskin details and rivets. But it bothers me a little that the pocket is not all leather lining, partially it is fabric. What is your opinion about this bag? To me it caught my eyes the first time I saw it years ago, it is so interesting with the box design and western style. But I would like to hear your opinion about this bag.
22791_bpblk_a0
 
  • Like
Reactions: BaguetteBlonde
#4
Oh tough choice! I love the yellow color as well, anything that is mustardy I tend to like haha But I am so in love with the saddle Rogue! The color looks great with the mini rivets.

For me I’d choose the Rogue. But if you love the yellow and want something different since you already have a Rogue then the yellow saddle bag. I’m not much help lol
 
#5
My vote is for the saddle bag since you already have a rogue. I am just not a fan of the page. It’s super small and I am not a fan of the colors on the one pictured.
 
#7
faintlymacabre said:
This is an amazing bag, especially with those gunmetal rivets and oxblood suede lining!
62b90e9f9446d1d2a93d874459da7f7d.jpg


I feel the Page is impractically tiny.

Sent from my ONEPLUS A5000 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Stop tempting me! [emoji23] I love that bag! [emoji7]

But I have bought a washed red and dusty rose rogue since the sale started lol
 
#11
I like the Saddle.

chenyinshanyi said:
recently I start to get obsessed with Coach 1941 line and tea rose stuff. I sold one LV trevi bag and a Valentino camera pouch bag to get more Coach bags since I love Coach's design way much more.
I bought a grey rogue 25 with tea rose, a white parker with tea rose and a dusty-rose-pink dinky with rivets.
I am still considering to get the below items, and want to hear your opinion which one I should get?
I really like the old vintage mustard yellow color Coach has in their 1941 line. So I am deciding between the Saddle and the Rogue 25?
rogue 25:
22797_bplqd_a0

Saddle:
image.jpg

Also I am thinking to get the black Page with snakeskin details and rivets. But it bothers me a little that the pocket is not all leather lining, partially it is fabric. What is your opinion about this bag? To me it caught my eyes the first time I saw it years ago, it is so interesting with the box design and western style. But I would like to hear your opinion about this bag.
22791_bpblk_a0
Click to expand...
 
#13
I am not a fan of the Page, not because of size exactly, it is how it is oriented and the flap on the top. I feel like it is hard to get things in and out of it because it is deeper and not wide. I much prefer the Dinky because it is wider. I would say that the Page can hold about the same if not a little more than the Dinky 24. The flap on the top was my deal breaker, it was just awkward trying to get into the bag. Normally flaps (like on the Dinky or Saddles) don't bother me.

If you don't want to get another Rogue then get the saddle. That Rogue is really pretty though! And I love Rogues.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top