Michael Kors What do YOU want next?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Trying to decide between a Selma, Sutton or Riley for my next MK purchase! Any opinions would be greatly appreciated, I have a large Hamilton already.


Personally i'd go with the riley for a real change, rather than the Selma or Sutton. I have a hamilton, selmas and a sutton and a riley is very different from any of them. All of them except the Riley are very structured stiff bags. I guess it depends what you want it for really.

Do you have a specific colour you want? There are some lovely colours around at the moment.
 
Personally i'd go with the riley for a real change, rather than the Selma or Sutton. I have a hamilton, selmas and a sutton and a riley is very different from any of them. All of them except the Riley are very structured stiff bags. I guess it depends what you want it for really.

Do you have a specific colour you want? There are some lovely colours around at the moment.

Just want it for everyday use. Do you think the Riley is a bit casual for the office? Ihaven't decided on a color yet, but I'd love something versatile like a gray. I do love the merlot color though!
 
I assume your large Hamilton is saffiano leather. If so, then I'd go with a soft leather bag for your next purchase. I would highly consider the large or medium Riley if I were you. I don't own a Riley, but love how it looks. :smile1:

Thank you for that! I quite like the look of the Riley, but I'm wondering if it'd look too casual for the office? I do love how it looks too!
 
All 3 are really great bags. I own 3 Selma's because they are so classy and simplistic. They will continue to look new after years of use. The Sutton has great organization. I don't have a Riley yet but it's on my wish list. Are you able to try them on to see which one you love more? :smile1:

Thank you for weighing in, good to know that the Selma continues to look new! I do love how classy they look, and I am partial to structured bags, but sometimes I feel I should expand my bag horizons!
Unfortunately no MK in the country I live in, but I'm making a trip to the US in late November and I'm planning to pick up the bag then.
 
Just want it for everyday use. Do you think the Riley is a bit casual for the office? Ihaven't decided on a color yet, but I'd love something versatile like a gray. I do love the merlot color though!


No I don't think it is casual but that is for the environment I work in, which is quite relaxed. I do think it would look good with more structured work wear as well however. I don't know if they do it in cinder but that is a lovely colour and merlot looks like a lovely rich colour.

If you really have to dress up for work, maybe the Selma is more the thing, due to the structured aspect of it. I use my ones all the time for work, more than any of my other MK's.

Grey is really versatile my hamilton is heather grey and goes with everything. I also have a claret bedford crossbody which is a bit lighter than merlot that I wear at weekends which goes with more than I thought it would.
 
No I don't think it is casual but that is for the environment I work in, which is quite relaxed. I do think it would look good with more structured work wear as well however. I don't know if they do it in cinder but that is a lovely colour and merlot looks like a lovely rich colour.

If you really have to dress up for work, maybe the Selma is more the thing, due to the structured aspect of it. I use my ones all the time for work, more than any of my other MK's.

Grey is really versatile my hamilton is heather grey and goes with everything. I also have a claret bedford crossbody which is a bit lighter than merlot that I wear at weekends which goes with more than I thought it would.

Thank you so much, glad to hear that your Selma's get a lot of use and that the Riley can still be a work bag! I was a bit worried about how the Merlot color would match wardrobe wise, so it is nice to hear that it goes with more than you thought!
 
Just want it for everyday use. Do you think the Riley is a bit casual for the office? Ihaven't decided on a color yet, but I'd love something versatile like a gray. I do love the merlot color though!

Thank you for that! I quite like the look of the Riley, but I'm wondering if it'd look too casual for the office? I do love how it looks too!

The Riley has a more casual silhouette than the Selma and Sutton, in my opinion. However, it can be dressed up or down depending on what you wear with it. If you are truly looking for a work/office bag, then I would suggest the Selma or the Sutton.

I use my Selmas almost every day for work. They're perfect for that because they are super structured and always look great no matter the weather due to the saffiano leather. You can't go wrong with a Selma for an every day work bag. My Sutton is tri-colored (navy/white/luggage) so is more of the weekend, casual bag in my collection.

Gray is such a nice, versatile color, too. I own 4 Selmas. One is heather grey (medium/dark grey), and I love it. My others are luggage, malachite (dark green), and sapphire.
 
Just want it for everyday use. Do you think the Riley is a bit casual for the office? Ihaven't decided on a color yet, but I'd love something versatile like a gray. I do love the merlot color though!
Have you seen the Merlot pebbled leather Traveler?? WOW! That bag is amazing! Wish they''d throw an outer pocket on it though. That's one thing great about the Riley. It has an awesome outer snap compartment on the back of it. I really like that for quick access to my cell phone. The Riley can most certainly be dressed up or down. You could easily wear it to the office and then off to a nice picnic after work! lol! Is a great all around bag. I love mine. Not really crazy about the crossbody strap though, so I added my own.

If you want to be different, I would look at those pebbled leather Travelers. They are very well structured. While the Selmas and Hamiltons are nice, everyone and their auntie, has one. I see way too many of them and it's just too much. Some folks enjoy following the fads, though. I always like to be more unique, with a look I can call my own. Fashion is a very personal thing. I'm just glad I finally figured out my own style. Took awhile! lol! Much f it has to do with your life style, height, weight, etc, and what looks good on YOU!
 
Last edited:
The Riley has a more casual silhouette than the Selma and Sutton, in my opinion. However, it can be dressed up or down depending on what you wear with it. If you are truly looking for a work/office bag, then I would suggest the Selma or the Sutton.

I use my Selmas almost every day for work. They're perfect for that because they are super structured and always look great no matter the weather due to the saffiano leather. You can't go wrong with a Selma for an every day work bag. My Sutton is tri-colored (navy/white/luggage) so is more of the weekend, casual bag in my collection.

Gray is such a nice, versatile color, too. I own 4 Selmas. One is heather grey (medium/dark grey), and I love it. My others are luggage, malachite (dark green), and sapphire.

Thank you! Looks like the Selma is quite a durable bag, and I am leaning towards an everyday office bag, so I will probably be getting a Selma while I'm in the US.
 
Have you seen the Merlot pebbled leather Traveler?? WOW! That bag is amazing! Wish they''d throw an outer pocket on it though. That's one thing great about the Riley. It has an awesome outer snap compartment on the back of it. I really like that for quick access to my cell phone. The Riley can most certainly be dressed up or down. You could easily wear it to the office and then off to a nice picnic after work! lol! Is a great all around bag. I love mine. Not really crazy about the crossbody strap though, so I added my own.

If you want to be different, I would look at those pebbled leather Travelers. They are very well structured. While the Selmas and Hamiltons are nice, everyone and their auntie, has one. I see way too many of them and it's just too much. Some folks enjoy following the fads, though. I always like to be more unique, with a look I can call my own. Fashion is a very personal thing. I'm just glad I finally figured out my own style. Took awhile! lol! Much f it has to do with your life style, height, weight, etc, and what looks good on YOU!

I will have to look at those pebbled leather travelers! They sound like something I would definitely consider, thank you so much for that! 😄
 
I made up my mind to get the Black with SHW Collins Stud. It has everything I love , beautiful thick leather. including a great outer pocket and a zipper top closure. I was going to get the Riley, but since I am not over joyed with the crossbody strap being too thin , I am going to wait for a good sale on the Collins Stud since they presently retail on the MK site for 421.00. . I think this bag is stunning!
CinthiaZ,
I'm a lurker here & saw your post on this bag. I knew immediately I had to have it! Classic black with SILVER hardware, a bit edgy & a back outside pocket....ahhhhhhh! I ordered it & it arrived today. Its perfect for me...not too big, not too small...just right. Zipper is tacked down on both sides & the zipper is like butter. The back outside pocket fits my Galaxy S5 with ease & I think it could even hold a slightly wider phone. The crossbody straps attach to their own D rings. Just all around great craftmanship & detail. I've been looking for a bag like this for a very long time & I'm beyond thrilled that you posted these photos & that I stumbled upon them! Did you order & if so, do you love it as much as I do?
THANKS AGAIN!
 
Top