I am very grateful for this thread because it makes me feel as if my duplicative closet contents are not weird or excessive. 
Brooklyns
I adore this bag and can't figure out why it wasn't more popular.
-3 Brooklyn 34s in oxblood, black and a khaki color whose actual name is escaping me right now. I would have gotten more, but had to walk myself back off the ledge.
Rogues
I have a major rogue problem and will probably get more Rogues one of these days.
-2 Rogue 39s in black and gray, but sadly I missed out on the oxblood (used to have 3, but realized the dark green one just wasn't for me)
-1 Rogue 36 in black
-2 Rogue 30s in oxblood and gray
-1 Rogue Tote in oxblood
Dinkys
I love big bags and the Dinky doesn't fit anything at all in my world, but there is something about the style that I adore -- it has such clean lines. I also love the Dinkys that come with the leather-in-chain option.
-Dinky in black with crystal tea rose
-Dinky in pink with rivets (I also have this style in a Callie)
-Dinky in gray logo-embossed leather
Callies
I don't actually like the Callie nearly as much as the Dinky, but I have a silver one I really liked and a pink one with rivets.
-2 Callies
Cashin Carry Totes
I have the biggest size in this one and I am not sure yet how many I have because that will be determined if I return one of the ones I just got from the outlets. So either 2 or 3 Cashin Totes.
Bedford Hobos
I think the Bedford Hobo is a truly perfect hobo.
-3 Bedford Hobos -- 2 in oxblood (thanks for not judging me
) and 1 in gray.
Cassie
-2 Cassies in pink and taupe
SLGs
Are we also talking SLGs? I loved everything about the Dreamer Card Case and have a bunch of those in a range of colors. I also have several of another card case whose name is also escaping me right now. (I should have sat down to write this out in the morning after coffee rather than later at night after a long day!)

Brooklyns
I adore this bag and can't figure out why it wasn't more popular.
-3 Brooklyn 34s in oxblood, black and a khaki color whose actual name is escaping me right now. I would have gotten more, but had to walk myself back off the ledge.
Rogues
I have a major rogue problem and will probably get more Rogues one of these days.
-2 Rogue 39s in black and gray, but sadly I missed out on the oxblood (used to have 3, but realized the dark green one just wasn't for me)
-1 Rogue 36 in black
-2 Rogue 30s in oxblood and gray
-1 Rogue Tote in oxblood
Dinkys
I love big bags and the Dinky doesn't fit anything at all in my world, but there is something about the style that I adore -- it has such clean lines. I also love the Dinkys that come with the leather-in-chain option.
-Dinky in black with crystal tea rose
-Dinky in pink with rivets (I also have this style in a Callie)
-Dinky in gray logo-embossed leather
Callies
I don't actually like the Callie nearly as much as the Dinky, but I have a silver one I really liked and a pink one with rivets.
-2 Callies
Cashin Carry Totes
I have the biggest size in this one and I am not sure yet how many I have because that will be determined if I return one of the ones I just got from the outlets. So either 2 or 3 Cashin Totes.
Bedford Hobos
I think the Bedford Hobo is a truly perfect hobo.
-3 Bedford Hobos -- 2 in oxblood (thanks for not judging me

Cassie
-2 Cassies in pink and taupe
SLGs
Are we also talking SLGs? I loved everything about the Dreamer Card Case and have a bunch of those in a range of colors. I also have several of another card case whose name is also escaping me right now. (I should have sat down to write this out in the morning after coffee rather than later at night after a long day!)