Vanessa Hudgens bag vs. Hilary Duff's

[camilliepoo]

Hi! I like both these bags --- they look almost identical though. Can anyone ID these bags and let me know if they are the same? TIA!!

 

[hellosunshine]

Balenciaga!

 

[camilliepoo]

are they both balenciaga? which bag do you like better?

 

[Izznit]

Hilary's has regular hardware but vanessa's has giant gold hardware. I think Vanessa's is the part time. not sure...

 

[saira1214]

They are both balenciaga. Hillary's has regular hardware and VH's has giant gold hardware. I personally like the regular hardware as it is more classic. However, I think GH looks good as well.

 

[camilliepoo]

Oh I see now -- Thanks so much everyone

 

[MonkeyGirl]

both balenciaga. hilarys bag is cuter imo.

 

[cjones99]

Both are Bbags. I personally like Hilarys better

 

[camilliepoo]

i agree hilary's wins

 

[LadyLouboutin08]

I guess I'm the minority, because I prefer Vanessa's bag. I like the giant hardware better.

 

[virgo8708]

I like them both. I think Vanessa's stands out more because of the giant gold hardware. I would rather have Vanessa bag but with SGH instead.

 

[LushBoutique]

i like both.

 

[woody]

Hillary's. the gold on Vanessa's looks a bit tacky.

 

[anghelq]

I love the giant hardware so I vote for vanessa!

 

[sugarplush]

Both are beautiful. The giant hardware is gonna be heavy though, but I think it adds that extra bling to the bag.