I was having the same problem for a couple of months... one day I would want the Hamilton and the next I would want the Selma... but I just couldn't get past thinking about the gorgeous hardware on the Hamilton ALL THE TIME... so I didn't even think about it anymore and got 2 Hamilton Totes... just received both of them this week and I'm over the moon happy with going with the Hamilton first.. Plus it's even got me rethinking if I want the larger N/S Selma over the regular Large... But you'll be like the rest of us and both bags will be in your collection .. that's just the way it goes with MK bags ... it seems that you have got to get one of all the designs and then you want all your favorite colors .. It's totally a sickness that I DON'T WONT no cure for....