Yes, I think the S is the right size for you. I also am sensitive to things around my wrist. I even feel the 5 motif but I don't mind it. The love cuff was too uncomfortable for me so I sold it. I find the bead on the edge of the perlee bangles so comfortable. I always know I have a bracelet on, but it does not bother me. If I could get myself to keep my bracelets on for a couple of weeks, never taking it off, I'm sure I would get used to it, but I don't want to. I don't like the combined polished and the floral design of the clover either. I'm all one or the other, thus the signature and the diamond bangles for me. Everyone is different.