May I ask who your insurance carrier is? You really scored if you found one that will just give you cash back.
Some of us discussed this in anther thread. How all the carriers have changed their policies in the last 5 years to the stand that one MUST replace jewelry, item for item.
They are not giving back money. (Ins Co claim there was a lot of fraud before when they didn't do this.) None of us could find one that just pays back without all the control.
So some of us aren't insuring.
I have a less is more policy on jewelry. What I have is very nice but don't have a ton of stuff. Although DH would disagree with the last part of that statement.
Chubb is still cash back, at least on my policy. But, like the others, due to fraud issues, they no longer will write a freestanding jewelry policy, you have to have another policy for your home or cars for them to do that now.
From what I understand there are companies that WILL write a cash out policy, you just pay significantly more in premiums.