Try stretching the toe box by wearing them with thick socks.Hello! I have wanted some Susanna's forever. I saw the lipstick pink ones on Pinterest and have been on the hunt for them ever since. I am a true 7/37 and the month of my bday a 36.5 and 37.5 popped up! They are both returnable and a super steal so I ordered both, planning on keeping the one that fits. So far I have the small size and the are snug on my pinky toe and loose on my heel. I don't like shoes to be tight on the toes but am anxious about the stretch factor. Advice!