@MyDogTink, thanks for sharing the boutique news. I'm so jealous of those in the area!! Regarding the moonstone/paraiba tourmaline ring prices

! The oval moonstone rings with a halo of color are beautiful. I'm partial to the one with sapphires.
I love the moonstone moon face rings!! I was just looking at those this AM.

Over the past year I've been mostly collecting her moonstone pieces, so a moon face ring has been haunting me, too. The Tolomeo ring is also beautiful, and as you say would complement your Tolomeo pendant. Have you seen either in person? I can usually decide pretty quickly when faced with options and am able to try on.
Regarding selling your VCA to fund, I say yes to that, too! That's assuming you'd not miss the earrings, and will be happier with your new TSC ring. I'm just finding, more and more, so few other jewelry brands really appeal to me like TSC does, I just don't see the same level of creativity. Up until recently, I thought I'd dip my toes into VCA and buy a few pieces, but have decided I'd really prefer to have more TSC instead. Let us know what you decide!