Talk me out of an engagement ring upgrade

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hi guys,

In case anyone is interested in the outcome of this. Hubby ended up surprising me with a slightly bigger round. He knows rounds are my favourite! Here is the set I wear now. 2.5ct round solitaire on a 4 prong for a change.

View attachment 5724555
Niiiiceee. My engagement ring is 1.7 carat round. I only noticed the visual difference to a bigger round when it was 1.7->2.2 carats. Only +.5 carats was worth writing home about, and that difference gets bigger the higher your carat weight. When I was e-ring shopping, I noticed a 2 carat emerald looked as big as a 1.5 carat round. This means if you want the visual difference of a bigger diamond compared to your current one, I'd guess you need at least a 2.5 carat emerald ($$$). I'm glad you ended up with a 2.5 carat round because it's very ~wow!
 
Hi guys,

In case anyone is interested in the outcome of this. Hubby ended up surprising me with a slightly bigger round. He knows rounds are my favourite! Here is the set I wear now. 2.5ct round solitaire on a 4 prong for a change.

View attachment 5724555
I think your upgrade is beautiful! In my opinion you definitely need a new eternity to pair with it. That beauty needs at least a 1.5 to 2 carat eternity.
 
Hi guys,

In case anyone is interested in the outcome of this. Hubby ended up surprising me with a slightly bigger round. He knows rounds are my favourite! Here is the set I wear now. 2.5ct round solitaire on a 4 prong for a change.

View attachment 5724555
Congratulations! The upgrade Diamond is beautiful and the rings look perfect together. I love how your e-ring is the show stopper as it should be, and they compliment your hand beautifully!
As for your question regarding a spacer, your jeweler would be the best person to advise you on that. We can’t judge by this photo. You’d be able to see if diamond rubs against prong or vise versa looking at your rings from the side. Your band is set in one of the more secure setting (as opposed to shared prong), so that’s a bonus.
Again, I think your set looks perfect! Congratulations!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: missie1
Top