I don't own any soft leather Hamiltons, but having both luggage and black makes total sense. Luggage is a casual, year-round color that goes with everything. Black can be dressed up and also goes with everything. I own two large n/s Hamilton totes (dark dune and black) and use them all the time. From what I've heard, the soft leather Hamiltons are made of really nice, soft, durable leather and are great if you like a soft, smooshy look to your bags. This is the same characteristic that is a negative to some. For some, a structured Hamilton in saffiano leather is the way to go. I prefer my Hamiltons in saffiano leather.