Share Your Latest VCA Purchase

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hadassa, I have saved your pictures as the benchmark of desirable malachite for the future. I don't own any of this stone but I want to add it to my collection and these photos are just incredible. I always look to see what they have in my store with an eye toward a future purchase but never have I seen such stunning coloration as this. I am interested in the 20 and after seeing your pictures, I will definitely not settle until they can provide similar quality. THANK YOU!!!

You are most welcome. I am happy to show the malachite benchmark.

It was lovingly chosen by my NM DSA, @texasgirliegirl and myself.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Stardust Andromeda
I personally would go for the lotus. It is the only piece you are in love with from your post. Bias here since it is on my wish list. If you are going to buy it at some point then you just saved yourself 30k vs spending as extra 10k now.
Yes but I’d want that 20 malachite eventually. If it had been a straight exchange the decision would have been harder but the extra 10k is so unappealing right now whereas a few months ago it would have been fine. Right now because of renovations I feel like I am bleeding money. Everything is costing so much more than I anticipated! It’s my first time renovating so I should’ve expected that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 880
The only item I ever purchased in which I felt like I had obtained my perfect goal are my diamond pave magic earrings. Even my Guilloche pieces which I was obsessed with initially I start to wonder about sometimes! I think it is because VCA is so expensive you really have to be quite sure about each item you buy. I’m happy with my collection and I know if funds were unlimited I wouldn’t question things so much. It’s just because I’m always wondering “wow was that worth that if I could’ve had this instead?”
Omg totally. I sometimes look at the pieces I just bought and wonder if they were really all that special since many people have them; and that if I have waited, I might find really unique heritage pieces at auction houses. The two times I had no doubts were my lotus earrings and a heritage diamond ring that means a lot to me. I found myself picking the smallest unlikable qualities on my pieces when they are new. :panic: But once I have lived happy experiences in them, then they have meaning to me and I find peace.
 
ok so i was finally able to go to my VCA and I exchanged my carnelian 20 for a malachite 20 and exchanged my onyx and gray mop between the finger ring for the frivole between the finger ring. i just felt i had too much alhambra it was starting to annoy me to look at that ring. the only negative is that everyone has that frivole, it's so ubiquitous. as for the malachite, i wished it was darker so it would match my aesthetic more but the color is fantastic on its own. then again the darker carnelian matched my aesthetic more but the color didn't pop on me and actually felt dull, especially mixed with onyx. SIGH im starting to think i'll never be happy. SA tried convincing me to exchange the ring and 20 and go for the lotus ring instead. i trie dit on. wow what a stunner! i was tempted but it would cost me an additional 10k and i am knee deep in renovations right now. i've also always wanted a 20 and the frivole isnt a bad consolation prize.

View attachment 4820100

View attachment 4820101

View attachment 4820102

View attachment 4820105

View attachment 4820106

View attachment 4820117

It sounds like you definitely want the malachite 20, although I am not sure you are 100% on this particular necklace. Can they get in some others for you to compare? As far as the Lotus ring goes, do you have a lot of dressy events? My lifestyle is so casual that I'd never wear it. I certainly see a lot of things in VCA that I love but would never get enough wear from them. So loving something is a good first qualification, and being able to wear it at least several times a year would be another qualification for me. Fortunately for me, I am in a state with no VCA boutiques (and the one in NM closed awhile ago), so I rarely see others wearing it. I can wear Alhambra or other VCA pieces as much as I want, and most people will not even know it's VCA! I think the malachite necklace is a beautiful piece to keep and wear as long as you are pleased with the stones.
 
It sounds like you definitely want the malachite 20, although I am not sure you are 100% on this particular necklace. Can they get in some others for you to compare? As far as the Lotus ring goes, do you have a lot of dressy events? My lifestyle is so casual that I'd never wear it. I certainly see a lot of things in VCA that I love but would never get enough wear from them. So loving something is a good first qualification, and being able to wear it at least several times a year would be another qualification for me. Fortunately for me, I am in a state with no VCA boutiques (and the one in NM closed awhile ago), so I rarely see others wearing it. I can wear Alhambra or other VCA pieces as much as I want, and most people will not even know it's VCA! I think the malachite necklace is a beautiful piece to keep and wear as long as you are pleased with the stones.
Thanks! Yes that was the other thing- although I do love the lotus and would find times to wear it (even on days when I’m just trying to be over the top and funky) it is something I’d be kind of self conscious about because it’s so big and sparkly, for sure. I would like to see how life unfolds with the pandemic...not ever wearing that ring as long as masks are necessary. Haven’t been feeling very fashionable or fancy since March. I wonder if I’m just not excited about anything because I’m depressed. As for stones...I would probably want a little darker but then would it fall flat again? This one really pops when I wear it. It’s not the forest green I imagined but with white striations are they ever really forest green?
 
Here we go! Hard to capture the color in the artificial light. I’ll try sunlight tomorrow. I haven’t even seen it myself yet in sunlight. In person it is green not as blue as it looks in some photos.
View attachment 4820854

View attachment 4820855

View attachment 4820856

View attachment 4820857

View attachment 4820858

View attachment 4820859

I think maybe the color would show better in photos if you take it off the green background. Try black or white, maybe? I believe the reasons these motifs look lighter is because the striations are tiny and spread across the whole motif, whereas some have areas of solid dark green and a smaller area with the light striations. I think both are beautiful, so it's just a matter of preference.

To your reply, I very much agree that during these times where we aren't really going anywhere (which definitely can be depressing), it's hard to think about how much we'd wear any jewelry!
 
Here we go! Hard to capture the color in the artificial light. I’ll try sunlight tomorrow. I haven’t even seen it myself yet in sunlight. In person it is green not as blue as it looks in some photos.
View attachment 4820854

View attachment 4820855

View attachment 4820856

View attachment 4820857

View attachment 4820858

View attachment 4820859

I will wait for your pics in sunlight before I can give a more constructive response. Just from these pics alone, there seems NOT to be enough contrast of the striations to the main green shade within the stone. @DS2006 gave a good explanation of this.

I do believe that you can request a few necklaces from which you can choose. Trust me, you will find one that will sing to you :tup:
 
This is to die for!!! Where did you find it?!

Christie's. To be honest I'm now kind of regretting the purchase (haven't even seen it yet!:sad:) because I was so excited that one was available, I got too wrapped up into it without thinking it through. I do not know how it will fit (all my VCA rings seem to be different sizes, even if on the same finger), it is not returnable, does not include COA, and I hate the 25% commission fee you pay on top of it.

Then I found one listed on VC that is probably a better size, with documentation, returnable, and no upcharge (though with taxes and customs fees it would still be priced ~2.5K over what I paid at auction). This experience (good or bad) will definitely inform future purchases. I'm not typically an impulse buyer.

Supposed to arrive tomorrow and I will post pics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 880 and kimber418
@Croissant, I can understand your dilemma. I took fresh pics of my bracelet for you to get an idea what should be acceptable striations and colour. These pics were taken in natural light (but it’s overcast here) in the original VCA box. I noticed the black background looked greyish, so you will have to imagine the gorgeous color.

VCA is too expensive to settle and if I can help one person NOT make the same EXPENSIVE mistakes I made (buying for a lifestyle I didn't have), then I feel satisfied in my heart.

Whatever you do, DO NOT SETTLE. You don’t seem wowed by your choices. If the Lotus ring will sing to you for years to come, look at the possible options to get that instead.

View attachment 4820755

View attachment 4820756
Wow!!! :love:
 
  • Like
Reactions: HADASSA
Top