For me, I would not get the WG Frivole earrings for two reasons...I am a little nervous getting wg Frivole just because I have only tried on the yg and felt they were a little small. I was thinking the wg might show up a little more than the yg. But I agree that there is some risk to ordering those whenever that becomes possible. I think I'd like the mop VA pair, but do you think that's too similar to the VA pave? I just don't want all my combinations to look redundant. Do you think I should keep the solid wg 5 motif since I have the wg mop now? I could wear the wg 5 motif with my turquoise Perlee earrings because I don't have a mate for those, although technically, those could be worn with the wg mop!
I think the WG version has too much white metal. For all metal, I like the YG much better. WG in all metal just does not have the same glamorous look and definitely not in a flower design. If it were a sleek contemporary design, it would look great, but not in a floral. The second reason is I do not think Frivole matches Alhambra. If these pieces were not VCA, I really do not think most people who attempt to coordinate would put them together. I do realize people throw all their VCA pieces on and love doing so. However, to me, just because it's VCA does not mean it matches. I try to look at each piece without any brand, and for me, I do not think the quatrefoil beaded edges matches with the Frivole flower and definitely not in all metal flower. That's just me though, and I know a lot of people wear both together. For a short while, I wore Frivole pave and Alhambra together, but it felt off to me, like I was just trying to wear pieces together just because they were VCA. I no longer wear them together anymore.
On the pieces... and of course this is only my opinion...
I personally would not keep the WG 5 motif. I think the MOP is stunning, and you can wear a set, bracelet, Magic necklace, and MOP earrings. That would be so gorgeous yet very casual, an everyday look. That would be your MOP set.
Then, you have your oynx set... Oynx Magic, VA pave earrings, and oynx pave 5 motif bracelet. Another gorgeous set and not duplicative at all.
With your two bracelets, MOP bracelet and oynx pave bracelet, I think it's perfect. I do not think the WG 5 motif adds much to your collection. If you were to get another bracelet, I would get a colorful stone. For me, the beauty of Alhambra is the stones.
On redundancy...
I do not think in your case the VA pave earrings and VA MOP earrings are redundant at all as you view the VA pave as dressier. The VA MOP would be a very wearable everyday piece. I have a friend that has VA MOP earrings, and that is all she wears, no other jewelry except her wedding ring. With her earrings alone, she makes a simple, but elegant statement. I see her VA MOP earrings, and those earrings speak for themselves. The WG Frivole earrings would absolutely not make the same statement to me.
Personally, I 100% think you should get the MOP earrings. You will see what I mean when you put them together with your other MOP pieces. It just falls into place and adds polish to even the most casual outfits... shorts! You can dress like a slob and still make the "casual elegance" statement with just a simple MOP set. Hard to explain, but try the set, and I think you will love the look it projects.
Finally, on your turquoise earrings... do you really love love love them? I know they are turquoise, and I love turquoise. I came super close to buying a Perlee turquoise set, but aside from the earrings, the ring and bracelet didn't look great at all. Hence for me, I did not get the earrings as I did not want to be stuck with just one turquoise piece and no buddy for it. I only want pieces that I will wear regularly, and those earrings were not it for me.
Yes, you can wear them with your MOP (and even oynx if you want to go eclectic), but do you really love that look or are you forcing yourself to wear it because you have them. If you don't love love love the turquoise Perlee earrings, I would sell them.
For me... if I had your fabulous pieces...
I would sell the WG 5 motif, sell the turquoise Perlee earrings, and get a WG MOP 20 motif.
I think seeing your love for long necklaces added to the fact you are not afraid of bold necklaces, a 20 motif would be fabulous on you. You also mentioned it's on your list. You already have the MOP earrings and bracelets. For me, one can never have too many WG MOP pieces, and if VCA made more WG MOP, I would definitely add to my collection. MOP really goes with everything, very versatile. If you ever wanted to bling out with VCA, you could wear the WG MOP 20 with your Magic oynx for a black & white art deco look. That would be gorgeous. You already have the bracelets. Your VCA theme would be two sets MOP and oynx, both of which are very interchangeable to mix and match depending on the different looks you want to create.
If you do not want the WG MOP 20 motif, you could get the Clover bangle. That is a very versatile piece, and it would also go with your non-VCA pieces. But for me, I would definitely sell the WG 5 motif and turquoise Perlee and get something else that adds to your collection.
Just my two cents. I know it's 100% preference, but those are m thoughts for another point of view. Hope that was helpful.