Second Kelly or not?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hello and happy new year fashion friends!

I have a dilemma and I wanted to get your opinion on it. I like to think of myself of somewhat of a minimalist and I only really want to collect one of each bag. Got my Birkin offer last year and was patiently waiting for a K28. Then I recently came across a vintage K32 in box calf in an exceptionally good price so I snagged it. But I still have a longing for an in-store Kelly offer and a Kelly in size 28. Should I settle since I already have a K32 and it's sufficient? Or should I also try to get a K28 store offer?

Reasons why I want the K28:
  • I want a smaller sized Kelly for more formal occasions (but how often do I actually attend them? rarely)
  • I want a Kelly in a more robust leather like togo as an alternative to the box leather
  • I love the in-store feeling of getting offered and feeling special (sorry just being frank ;P)
  • The Kelly prices keep going up and I fear that if I don't buy it I will "regret" it one day and buy one later down the road at a higher price?
Reasons why I am hesitating:
  • Already have a K32 and I know that the Kelly style isn't the one I tend to go for most. I like casual slouchy bags so I'm usually reaching for my Picotin or Evelyne. Even my Birkin only gets a few days of wear per year. And I prefer the Birkin to the Kelly.
  • I'm not really a shoulder bag kind of girl and I find the closure on the Kelly too fussy
  • There is really no color that I need in a bag. I have all my colors covered now too so I'll probably duplicate and ask for a Kelly in black or etoupe...
  • The price - it's a lot to pay for a bag that I'll use only a handful of times per year (but some argue it's an "investment"...) hmm..
Would love to hear your thoughts! Thanks for reading!
I enjoyed watching the wheels turn.
 
I would sell the Box Kelly and get the Kelly you really want. Or request the Kelly from the store and when it arrives you can compare with the Box and see if you want to sell it or keep both. In my store I don't see that many retourne offers but that may be due to local preference - I shop in London.

A Kelly in Togo is quite casual IMO and slouchy. I prefer sellier for this reason. I don't think a Kelly retourne in 28 is that suitable for formal occasions (that you mention) IMO but I guess it depends on the occasion and your style. Maybe a k25 would be better or a K20.
 
Top