Proenza Schouler PS1 - old version vs. new version?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Hi babycakes, this is so helpful to know - thank you so much. As I read on though I'm getting confused.

Your PS1, does it come with the PS insignia on the zippers, hardware & underneath your clasp? Also what colour & from which season is your PS1 from?

Thanks in advance!

Hi there !!

I've recently managed to see more of the bags, and have purchased a PS1 and a Keep All myself, so I can confirm some of the changes .

The new leathers (at least the tag on my Keep All) is marked as calf leather, whereas I believe the old ones are lamb.
I saw an older version of the White PS1 in large at The Room and the leather was a lot softer and more slouchy. Before I saw them in person, I ha though I'd prefer them to be lambskin, as it makes the bag look more slouchy and worn, which I think looks good on the ps1...however after having seen it myself, I realized that the lambskin version doesn't hold the shape of the bag well at all, because even though it was new, the edges were already beginning to curl etc., and the bag just doesn't look good at all...so in the end I think the change of leather helps in the longevity of the bag.

However, I think that in the midnight, the colour looks better in the older leather...because I happened to see it in the new version, and it didn't look appealing at all...I think the lambskin took the dye better and made it look more jewel toned. The blue was seemingly darker and duller in calf, but that's just my opinion.

I've heard that the calf skin also addresse the colour change issue better, because the old leathers, especially the smoke, was known to be prone to colour change.

I've also heard that they addressed the hardware chipping problem in the new versions of the black.

The clasp on the PS1 used to be glued on, as I saw in on the white one, but the newer ones are screwed on, which prevents the hardware from falling off, as some members have experienced.

Another change is that on the newer versions, the tag is fastened tobte strap instead of jut clipped on...which is a good thing because other members have mentioned problems with the tag falling of etc., and on the white bag I saw, even though it was new, the tag was gone, likely taken by someone while it was on display at the store.

I don't know when they started implementing the changes, as I am new to the bags myself and only bought mine recently, and they were already the newer version.

I used to want the older version more, because they took the colour better, but now I think I do prefer the new ones, as there have been many problems with the older ones.

Sorry for the long post !!
 
Hi again, could anyone share with me what does it mean exactly by the "clasp is screwed on vs. glued on"? Does this mean that the older PS1 have their clasps glued on? @__@.

Does anyone know from which year onwards this was the new switch?

Hi there !!

The clasp on the PS1 used to be glued on, as I saw in on the white one, but the newer ones are screwed on, which prevents the hardware from falling off, as some members have experienced.

Another change is that on the newer versions, the tag is fastened tobte strap instead of jut clipped on...which is a good thing because other members have mentioned problems with the tag falling of etc., and on the white bag I saw, even though it was new, the tag was gone, likely taken by someone while it was on display at the store.

Hi Elliespurse, thank you for this link - I couldn't quite search though which photos you were referring to showing the screws... do these photos show the "screw on" vs. the "glued on" clasps?

Thanks in advance!

Hi, there's a pic in this thread showing the screws under the flap http://forum.purseblog.com/proenza-...ere-reference-only-633763-3.html#post16977222
 
Hi again, could anyone share with me what does it mean exactly by the "clasp is screwed on vs. glued on"? Does this mean that the older PS1 have their clasps glued on? @__@.

Does anyone know from which year onwards this was the new switch?



Hi Elliespurse, thank you for this link - I couldn't quite search though which photos you were referring to showing the screws... do these photos show the "screw on" vs. the "glued on" clasps?

Thanks in advance!

Hi, look through that thread but some pics seems to be removed. The change was gradually introduced during 2010 so it's old now.
 
Hi Ellie! Thanks so much for responding, yes I couldn't see the photos that was referenced earlier - this means that all PS1s 2010 and after comes with screwed on clasps?

I can't imagine hardware being "glued on" on such an expensive bag, which was why I wanted to see how "well they could have been glued on". Must be some expensive glue they were using @__@!

Hi, look through that thread but some pics seems to be removed. The change was gradually introduced during 2010 so it's old now.
 
Hi babycakes, this is so helpful to know - thank you so much. As I read on though I'm getting confused.

Your PS1, does it come with the PS insignia on the zippers, hardware & underneath your clasp? Also what colour & from which season is your PS1 from?

Thanks in advance!

Hi there !

Both of mine are from SS2012 if I remember correctly...I have a PS1 in smoke and a keepall in Coral; and yes the hardware has the PS insignia on them =)
 
Top