I think your bag looks beautiful! But if puffy and shiny quilts are important to you, then you should exchange it and get something you LOVE.
If you keep it you might still end up chasing a puffy and shiny CF later down the road! However, if this was super difficult to get and you're not willing to pay more when a puffy and shiny CF comes along (you know, price increases... not saying there is one coming up of course, but it's just inevitable), then I say keep it because to me it looks gorgeous! Personally, I prefer a matte caviar to a shiny caviar!
Let us know what you finally decide to do!

Let us know what you finally decide to do!