Please help me decide between two diamond cross pendants

[surfergirljen]

The tiffany ones are NOT equal length and width wise... think about it, that would make it a + !! I can tell you with 100% certainty that they aren't! No cross is...

 

[BurgundyRose]

Makes perfect sense. Tiffany's Customer service (by phone) is off.

 

[BurgundyRose]

weird, right?

I think the ebay measurements make sense, at least!

Anyway, I only mentioned the measurements because it seemed like something you were listing as a "pro" for Tiffany. So, if the measurements are actually quite similar between the two crosses, then that factor gets taken out of consideration..... therefore: I would go with the Blue Nile cross and use the rest of that money for something else that I love-- maybe even something from Tiffany!

Yes - like maybe a Tiffany chain to use on the Blue Nile cross.

 

[VuittonsLover]

are crosses suppose to be symetrical..? I always thought it was longer then it was wide.

I would go with Blue Nile..... Price, length of chain.. carat weight...

And I bet the diamonds are even better quality then Tiffany.

A brand... doesn't make the diamonds better.

 

[BurgundyRose]

Thanks. I agree and am bending towards Blue Nile for sure. I just wish I could see it before I order. They do have a 30 day refund policy.

And I have no idea why I thought the cross would be symetrical. Doesn't make sense.

 

[decisionsx2]

Yes - like maybe a Tiffany chain to use on the Blue Nile cross.

The world is your oyster! lol

 

[exotikittenx]

I would have one made like the one you prefer at a local jeweler's for the BlueNile price point (or less if possible), and take that extra money from the Tiffany's price and go on a nice vacation or get a pair of matching diamond earrings.

I think it's nicer to support a local business. Make sure to see samples of their custom work first!