Please help me choose: Which Tiffany dot charm?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

M

MillyT

O.G.
Dec 4, 2011
155
0
#1
Lovely tPF Ladies,

I need your help! I suddenly fall in love with these little charms. I like all three of them but can only get one, for now. I have not seen them IRL and that makes it harder for me to choose. For more info, I wear mostly gray, navy, white, or cream. I am leaning towards the turquoise as it's more of a safe bet. Oh and I plan to wear it on a YG oval link chain if that matters.

Can you please help me to choose? More suggestions? Thank you!
 

Attachments

  • amethyst.jpg
    amethyst.jpg
    7.4 KB · Views: 1,402
  • carnelian.jpg
    carnelian.jpg
    6.4 KB · Views: 1,386
  • turquoise.jpg
    turquoise.jpg
    2.9 KB · Views: 1,384
Last edited:
#2
I think either the turquoise or the red. I originally thought of the turquoise just because I am always drawn to blue. But red and blue is such a classic, if you wear navy a lot. Its very nautical.
 
#8
I like the red. Is it carnelian? I think the turquoise is priced higher unnecessarily, that color and size does not warrant it.
I have the dot in chrysophase ( green) and I wear it a lot. I think the dots look best in the opaque stones. Originally I wanted the aqua, but the translucent ones were very pale irl and I could see my skin through them. Too pale.
 
#9
The carnelian's more orange in person. I think the turquoise is the most versatile. I very much want the garnet, but it's $600, whereas the rest are only $300, I think!
 
#10
MillyT said:
Lovely tPF Ladies,

I need your help! I suddenly fall in love with these little charms. I like all three of them but can only get one, for now. I have not seen them IRL and that makes it harder for me to choose. For more info, I wear mostly gray, navy, white, or cream. I am leaning towards the turquoise as it's more of a safe bet. Oh and I plan to wear it on a YG oval link chain if that matters.

Can you please help me to choose? More suggestions? Thank you!
Click to expand...

Personally I love the first one. The colors are stunning.
 
Last edited:
#11
I usually am not drawn to reds, but the carnelian IRL is such a pretty coral-y red that it's TDF. My vote goes for the carnelian just because I think it would be the most versatile and would be a lovely pop of color to any number of outfits!
 
#12
It would be a tough choice between the turquoise and the carnelian, but I think the carnelian would win out. Red happens to be my lucky color, and turquoise can be inconsistent. I also like it with the chunkier chain. Really, you can't go wrong, though. It'll be a beautiful choice either way.

If you wind up getting one, would you mind doing a modeling shot? I've been dying to see one of these outside Tiffany's stock photos.
 
#13
Here is a quick pic of mine on regular 16" Tiffany chain.
e5462db11a5ed7357a267c9f29f672a3.jpg
 
#14
Thank you so much for the modeling shot! It really helped me visualizing the size. And It looks so pretty on you! I was really drawn to the Chrysoprase. The only reason I didn't include this as a choice is my MIL gave me a green stone pendant/ring set.

Kitsunegrl said:
Here is a quick pic of mine on regular 16" Tiffany chain.
e5462db11a5ed7357a267c9f29f672a3.jpg
Click to expand...
 
#15
Thank you for your opinion. Could you please elaborate on turquoise being inconsistent? I am very ignorant about colored gemstones.
vintagefinds said:
It would be a tough choice between the turquoise and the carnelian, but I think the carnelian would win out. Red happens to be my lucky color, and turquoise can be inconsistent. I also like it with the chunkier chain. Really, you can't go wrong, though. It'll be a beautiful choice either way.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top