Please help me choose between this two keys!!!!

[-josy]

Heelloo! Please hellpp!!!! I like them both, but i have to choose onee!
1. Gold black enamel knot key
2. Gold trefoil key
I am leaning towards #1 but I have read that tiffany enamel is very delicate, but I dont own any enamel piece.
Opinions pleasee!

 

[MillyT]

I've tried the knot key w/ matte finish in store and it's really pretty. I like the open knot key as well. Have fun deciding !

 

[HauteRN]

I don't care for the one with black (it's the shape that makes me not care for it, not the enamel).

I like the second one

 

[NikkisABagGirl]

I like the black enamel against the yellow gold. I like the first one.

 

[arnott]

2nd one.

 

[Riima]

I'm not fond of the first one either, so 2nd for me

 

[emchhardy]

I don't care for the first one so another vote for #2.

 

[cr3atur3comfort]

i vote for the first. the contrast and design is gorgeous.
i have a few tiffany bangles with enamel and they knock together a lot but it hasnt falled out or chipped. i would think enamel on a pendant would be hardier and not prone to much knocking etc. so i dont think u have anything to worry about.

 

[Greentea]

#2 -

 

[Ali7364]

The second one.

I like the simplicity of it better. Plus, I would worry about the enamel over time. Especially if you ever sleep or shower in it much.

 

[sleepykitten]

i like the look of the 2nd

 

[Dett]

Like the black enamel too. Nice contrast. Enamel are Hardy if you wear it as pendant. Won't be a problem.

 

[Candice0985]

I like the 2nd one, my sister has it in silver and it looks great with everything she wears.

 

[TrinketTattle]

2nd one! I've also heard that enamel tends to chip, which is really a pity because it looks great.

 

[beachy10]

#2