Having a similar struggle, however I'm debating the Large Selma in Peanut or Luggage. The Peanut is on sale and can be combined with the current sale bringing it down to $233.50 and I kind of like the lighter shade as opposed to the darker Luggage colour. I'm very picky though in regards to matching my accessories - most of my leather watches are closer to the luggage colour; same with my footwear so I'm stuck!
LOL that's funny! I like to match my accessories too! I have some brown boots and trying to figure out which color bags would go better with it, peanut or luggage. So I'm stuck too! LOL.