Need opinions on Rolex dial change!

[blumster]

Hi everyone!
I really need your help and opinions! This past week, I changed the dial on my 36mm Rolex datejust from silver jubilee/diamond to silver diamond dial. It arrived yesterday and to my surprise, the AD put on a silver diamond dial but along the outer edge, is also some added details and small roman numerals. I do love this dial that he sent but I just don't know if I would prefer the other dial. I would love to get your thoughts on each of which you like better and why. Thanks so much in advance....

 

[lilmountaingirl]

It might be the only one you can currently get for your watch.

 

[lilmountaingirl]

Did you use an authorized dealer or a secondary party?

 

[blumster]

Rolex AD

 

[blumster]

My understanding is that I can get either. It's a lateral change since my dial already had the diamonds....

 

[ame]

I kinda like the numerals added. I REALLY had to stare to see the difference.

 

[blumster]

I kinda like the numerals added. I REALLY had to stare to see the difference.

I know, the difference is very minor! I am trying to decide if the numerals take away from the diamond markers at all or make the face look crowded. Do I like the simpler, cleaner dial without or the addition which I think makes it look a little "sportier" maybe? Thoughts? I am SO conflicted- love them both!

 

[Bag*Snob]

I prefer the first dial but it is not a jubilee. I think I would have kept the diamond jubilee instead of a diamond on plain silver.

 

[kim_mac]

i like plain over jubilee. both dials (with and without romans) look nice!

 

[blumster]

i like plain over jubilee. both dials (with and without romans) look nice!

I found jubillee dial too busy for my eyes. I like simplicity. Between the two of these, do you like one over the other? How does each read to you? Thanks!

 

[nc.girl]

I love the Roman numerals! I don't think it looks too busy at all with the diamonds and Roman numerals...they go really well together IMO.

 

[originalheather]

I think both look great but if given the choice, I would choose no roman numerals. Like you, I like simplicity.

 

[akoko]

I also prefer cleaner/ more simple looks, so I would choose no roman numerals

 

[DS2006]

I also prefer the plain silver dial with diamond markers. I like the roman numerals big like on Cartier watches!

 

[blumster]

thanks for everyone's responses. More opinions welcome