Need help choosing a stone PLEASE

Please help me choose a stone! Thanks!

  • Radiant

  • Cushion

Results are only viewable after voting.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#17
skyqueen said:
Both gorgeous!
With that being said...you will be losing carat weight buying a deeper stone, can't see a carat weight difference between the two stones. Between the two the cushion is facing up whiter, just slightly, IMHO.
Since you have seen them both IRL...I think you'll have to use your gut feeling when choosing.
Is this the setting you're considering?
Click to expand...

Thanks skyqueen! I prefer the halo with the split shank, the one in the picture that the radiant is currently in, but putting the cushion in that setting. The difference is minimal in the stone, but the cushion does appear larger once set. It's a Daussi cushion and with the depth they are able to open the mounting more than the radiant helping to give more width to it once set. I just need help from everyone on this forum as to which they think is a prettier stone, since I am driving myself crazy!!! The radiant is 10.55 x 8.10 and the cushion is 11.35 x 8.55.
 
#23
skyqueen said:
Both gorgeous!
With that being said...you will be losing carat weight buying a deeper stone, can't see a carat weight difference between the two stones. Between the two the cushion is facing up whiter, just slightly, IMHO.
Since you have seen them both IRL...I think you'll have to use your gut feeling when choosing.
Is this the setting you're considering?
Click to expand...

ame said:
Have you seen ASETs of either stone?
Click to expand...

No, I have not. I don't know much about that. The radiant I have time on, but the cushion needs to be purchased or shipped out Monday as someone else is interested in it. Would that be really beneficial in helping to determine which stone is best? Thanks
 
#24
Well, there will be other cushions if you don't take this one. However if THIS one was IT, you'd know. I think your hesitation to let the radiant go means you don't totally LOVE this cushion.
 
#25
in general i prefer cushions over radiants. there are a ton of shapes and cuts among cushions so i would keep searching until you find the right one. between the two, i prefer the cushion. D color is so white, and the depth adds a lot of character to the stone.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top