Necklace options

[PinkGlitterStar]

I am trying to decide between a vintage vca onyx necklace or the cartier baby love necklace. Does anyone have both? I know they are very different, but I truly am having a hard time choosing. I already have multiple cartier pieces so this would be my first vca. I enjoy the love collection a lot, but I also am not sure how well I think the screw motif would show up on the small necklace rings. I am not interested in having diamonds in either. I would be purchasing either one in Yellow gold. Can you all help with opinions or thoughts? If you have either are there any pros or cons to either?

 

[KristenG]

I have both and would definitely pick the VCA first so you have variety since you own multiple Cartier pieces. I bought the onyx Alhambra as my first VCA piece and the baby Love necklace 2 years later. Definitely the right choice! Good luck!

 

[Swanky]

Pics?

 

[sleepydoc.]

Not sure which Cartier necklace that is. The one with 2 interlocking rings?

 

[KristenG]

I believe this is the “baby Love” the OP is referencing?

 

[Swanky]

I don't have either necklace, I assume others may need pics of both

 

[sparklebunny]

View attachment 5801773

I believe this is the “baby Love” the OP is referencing?

TBH, while this is a nice design, the rings seemed very small to me. I tried it on in a store last year and felt underwhelmed by their size.

 

[LuckyMe14]

VCA

 

[PinkGlitterStar]

View attachment 5801773

I believe this is the “baby Love” the OP is referencing?

Yes this is it thank you!!

 

[PinkGlitterStar]

Sorry for not initially uploading pics!

 

[lvchanellvr]

I voted for the VCA necklace; I find the Cartier necklace underwhelming. The Cartier necklace reminds me of the Tiffany's 1837 Interlocking necklace. I own this necklace in sterling silver and I would not buy the YG version.

 

[Purrsey]

Between this two, I’d prefer the vca. I feel the black has a nice contrast against the skin; makes a nice everyday piece because the clover is the right size. Just a month ago I was thinking of getting one too (in another stone) but in the end I decided to do a bespoke piece (just to have something differently my own).

I’ve not tried the Cartier piece (used to own the bracelet though). There’s a YouTuber who wears in all her videos. Personally I don’t feel it stands out much.

 

[880]

VCA, but they are so different, perhaps looks for a third that you truly love

 

[A bottle of Red]

@Purrsey I would love to see your custom necklace if you care to share
Op, personally I don't like the design of the Cartier because it looks like just a ring or two threaded onto a chain.

 

[Purrsey]

@Purrsey I would love to see your custom necklace if you care to share
Op, personally I don't like the design of the Cartier because it looks like just a ring or two threaded onto a chain.

Sure It’s not ready yet (just made a little tweak on the design with the jeweller 2days ago before it was sent to be made). I should be expecting it to be done by end of the month. As much as he is a recommended bespoke jeweller, it still is a little nerve wrecking like what if I don’t like how it turns out. Well, I’ll just have to wait and see.
I’ve been wearing WG solitaire necklace almost all my life. Now I want a RG piece for a change which likewise I want to wear 24/7.