Thanks crochetbella!
Msflutter - I looked at the hippie bag, too, but decided that it was too small for what I wanted. Plus, I'd rather have a shoulder bag for that amount of money, I don't know why. I'm glad you're loving yours as much as I'm loving mine!
Pompilit - Thanks! I love the whiskey colour. I mostly wear shades of browns or other "autumn" colours, and don't really wear much black, so for me there was no question about which colour to get. Plus, I feel like the whiskey can be worn with black but that a black bag can really only be worn with black or other dark colours. That's just me, though. I actually remember reading something similar in one of the BBC What Not To Wear books. Trinny and Susannah recommended getting a brown bag instead of black for that reason.
Anyway, I think that the whiskey is such a nice, rich shade that it can be worn with most things. I also like that it'll be good all year round.
Good luck and let us know which one you decide on!