I am so glad I stumbled upon this post because I've been toying with purchasing a TB clutch, over the holiday I saw people come by our store with it on and it is really a stunning bag. I did get the Clay crossbody for Christmas which I love as it does not scream a label but I still find myself yearning over this bag. I went by the store today to look at the Reva vs, the Amanda and basically they are the sample size with the exception of the Reva being a smooth leather with a large gold logo. I think I am still drawn to the Amanda more but I see that the newer ones are like your red one with the slightly smaller logo. You say that you like your black one better - does this have to do with the logo or is it the color bag? I'm struggling with this decision and really think black shows this bag off best in my opinion but curious to know your thoughts since you have both.