My almost 1 Year Post-op Rhinoplasty Surgery with Dr. Kim at ITEM

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Seoulmate_92

Member
Jan 21, 2020
53
47
Hello Everyone,

I just wanted to write about my nose job surgery experience at ITEM Clinic with Dr. Kim. Before we get into the review, I'd like to mention the reason I wanted to get my nose done in the first place. Around the age of 14, I became insecure about my nose. I felt like my nose was too wide for my face and thought I would look prettier with a less wide/bulbous nose. My goal was not to change my nose and look like someone else but to enhance my nose so that I'd look like a prettier version of myself. Now, let's get started with the review. In Feb 2020, I consulted with three clinics and decided to get my surgery done at ITEM for numerous reasons.

1. I met with a girl who had gotten her rhinoplasty surgery with Dr. Kim, she had a similar (thick) nose to mine, and her results were beautiful!

2. Dr. Kim made me feel comfortable because he was direct, and he did not rush our consultation. He kept asking me if I had any more questions, and he answered each-and-every one of them.

3. Joy was the most amazing translator I've ever met. She was kind, responsive, and tried her hardest to help me out in any way possible, especially post-surgery, but I'll talk more about that later on.


On the day of my consultation, Dr. Kim and I went over what I wanted. I told him I wanted an alar reduction, tip plasty, silicone implant, and to narrow the overall look of my nose. Dr. Kim had suggested that I didn't need the silicone implant because I already had a defined nose bridge (I didn't realize that until he pointed that out.) I agreed but told him I thought the silicone implant might give my nose more definition, so we agreed to use a small implant. No more than 2/2.5 mm max.

Here are some before pictures: As you can see, I have really thick skin, a wide nose, and flared alar rims.
IMG_5528.JPGIMG_5553.JPGIMG_5554.JPG


My surgery date was on February 14th. I know right, how romantic lol. I met with Joy, did some paperwork, met with Dr. Kim, and we went over the surgery plans once again. As we were going over the plans, I realized we didn't address him narrowing down my nasal bone, so I asked him if he could do so, and he first said he didn't think I needed it and then he said he thought it would be safer to wait and see if I wanted it done after this surgery. Honestly, I had a bad feeling once he said that because I knew that's one thing I wanted to get done because I had a wide nose, so narrowing the nasal bone would've helped with the overall look. I also did NOT want to pay to get my nose done twice, but at that point, it was too late, and I didn't want to second guess him or put pressure on him to do it since he was against it at that moment. So, I went ahead and had the surgery.

Here are some post-surgery pictures: This was on the 7th day when I got my cast removed. My nose was covered with blackheads and it was super swollen for about 3 months.
IMG_5533.jpgIMG_5532.JPG


My surgery was perfect! I woke up in the recovery room feeling thirsty as hell! My throat was so dry, and I had to wait to drink water. The clinic was very nice to provide me with everything I needed for my post-surgery recovery. Their recovery bag included my medications, two ice/heating pads, pumpkin juice, q-tips, petroleum jelly, extra gauze, and a face mask.

Here are some pictures of what's provided in the post-surgery bag.
IMG_5531.JPG

My post-surgery experience was great! My surgery price included all of my post-op appointments. Dr. Kim always took his time to analyze my nose and answer all of my questions. Joy was attentive and responded to all of my messages right away. I'm not going to lie, after my cast removal, I was depressed for the first three months of my recovery. First of all, my nose bridge and nose tip were extremely high. I couldn't believe it! Dr. Kim had said I didn't need an implant in the first place, so I was shocked when I saw my nose bridge. Secondly, I wasn't aware that I wasn't going to be able to smile for months! The healing process varies from person to person, but I had my surgery on Feb 14th, and I wasn't able to fully smile until the end of April. My smile looked weird for a VERY long time. Lastly, I had a hard time breathing out of my right nostril. Because of those three issues, I kept messaging Joy all day and night, but she was so patient with me. Always responded to all of my questions and concerns nicely and politely.

Here are some pictures showing my bridge now. I think it's nice for those who like high nose bridges, but I don't like it nor do I think it fits my face. The first picture is without makeup and the second picture is with makeup.

IMG_5538.JPGIMG_5539.JPG

I am getting close to my one-year mark so here are my final thoughts. Overall, I think Dr. Kim did a good job, but I think he’s done better on other patients. I'll start with the cons. I wish Dr. Kim had narrowed my nose as I asked. I am still insecure about how the left side of my nose bone is wider than the right. I think my results would have been nicer had he performed an osteotomy. The other thing I am not happy with is the height of my bridge. When I reached out to Joy, I learned that Dr. Kim had used a 3mm implant, which explains why my nose bridge is this high. Joy explained that Dr. Kim went with the 3mm implant because he had to shave down a small bump on my nose, but I don't think a 3mm implant was necessary. On a lighter note... the tip of my nose did drop, and it looks beautiful. Also, my nostril breathing issue has gotten better, but it has not been resolved. Dr. Kim did ask me to go see an ENT doctor, but I'm an English teacher who can't request time off during the school year, so I plan to see an ENT doctor this week. I'll end this review with the pros. While it may sound like I'm unhappy, I think the pros outweigh the cons in my opinion. My surgery went well, my post-surgery care was great! The post-surgery communication was magnificent. I would only advise these four things for anyone who plans to have surgery.

1. Do your research! Know exactly what you want… from the procedures to the silicone sizes.

2. Be firm about what you want. I wanted an osteotomy, so I should have made sure I had gotten it.

3. Go to a safe and honest clinic that covers all of your post-surgery appointments and medications. ITEM was amazing in that department. I wasn't worried about shadow doctors or something going wrong with my anesthesia.

4. Know that the recovery process is LONG, but so worth it!

So, would I recommend Dr. Kim? Yes, I would. As I mentioned earlier, aside from my nose bridge being too high and him not narrowing down my nose, everything else was perfect. I was told by someone who just had their surgery at ITEM that Dr. Kim will be moving to his own clinic so please keep that in mind. If you have any questions, feel free to message me or leave a comment below.

Here are some of my most recent pictures: My new nose looks much better, but I would have been a lot more satisfied if the bridge of my nose was lower and my nasal bone was narrowed. I have thick skin, so I don’t think this is the final result. I might update this review if there are any changes. Thanks for reading, and I hope you found this review helpful.

IMG_5552 2.jpgIMG_5544.JPGIMG_5549.JPGIMG_5548 2.jpg



****PS: This isn't a promotional review. I paid for my entire surgery in full and did not receive anything in return.
 
Thanks for writing this review! I recently had my surgery with Dr. Kim, too, and was just thinking I wish people who were close to +1 year post-op would update. Your nose looks very natural yet more defined now. I like that he gave you a pretty/elegant, but not overly-done result. What did he use in the tip, and are you planning to do a revision and if so, with them?
Hey Mochi!

I think I saw your messages in one of the Kakao chats lol! I believe it was donated rib that was used at the tip. Joy told me my surgery plans were: Rhinoplasty, (septum cartilage + rib material), 3mm silicon implant, alar reduction (incision approach method). I love how it doesn't look overly done, but I do wish he had done a lateral osteotomy as well. It would have made a huge difference, but he didn't think it was needed and told me to wait. I'm going to the clinic next Thursday to meet with Dr. Kim and see if a revision is on the table. I would like to narrow my nose a little and lower the bridge of my nose. I really like Dr. Kim so I would prefer to stick with him if I do decide on the revision.

Message me if you have any other questions. I would love to hear about your experience as well :smile:
 
  • Like
Reactions: _Mochi_
Hello Everyone,

I just wanted to write about my nose job surgery experience at ITEM Clinic with Dr. Kim. Before we get into the review, I'd like to mention the reason I wanted to get my nose done in the first place. Around the age of 14, I became insecure about my nose. I felt like my nose was too wide for my face and thought I would look prettier with a less wide/bulbous nose. My goal was not to change my nose and look like someone else but to enhance my nose so that I'd look like a prettier version of myself. Now, let's get started with the review. In Feb 2020, I consulted with three clinics and decided to get my surgery done at ITEM for numerous reasons.

1. I met with a girl who had gotten her rhinoplasty surgery with Dr. Kim, she had a similar (thick) nose to mine, and her results were beautiful!

2. Dr. Kim made me feel comfortable because he was direct, and he did not rush our consultation. He kept asking me if I had any more questions, and he answered each-and-every one of them.

3. Joy was the most amazing translator I've ever met. She was kind, responsive, and tried her hardest to help me out in any way possible, especially post-surgery, but I'll talk more about that later on.


On the day of my consultation, Dr. Kim and I went over what I wanted. I told him I wanted an alar reduction, tip plasty, silicone implant, and to narrow the overall look of my nose. Dr. Kim had suggested that I didn't need the silicone implant because I already had a defined nose bridge (I didn't realize that until he pointed that out.) I agreed but told him I thought the silicone implant might give my nose more definition, so we agreed to use a small implant. No more than 2/2.5 mm max.

Here are some before pictures: As you can see, I have really thick skin, a wide nose, and flared alar rims.
View attachment 4971306View attachment 4971304View attachment 4971307


My surgery date was on February 14th. I know right, how romantic lol. I met with Joy, did some paperwork, met with Dr. Kim, and we went over the surgery plans once again. As we were going over the plans, I realized we didn't address him narrowing down my nasal bone, so I asked him if he could do so, and he first said he didn't think I needed it and then he said he thought it would be safer to wait and see if I wanted it done after this surgery. Honestly, I had a bad feeling once he said that because I knew that's one thing I wanted to get done because I had a wide nose, so narrowing the nasal bone would've helped with the overall look. I also did NOT want to pay to get my nose done twice, but at that point, it was too late, and I didn't want to second guess him or put pressure on him to do it since he was against it at that moment. So, I went ahead and had the surgery.

Here are some post-surgery pictures: This was on the 7th day when I got my cast removed. My nose was covered with blackheads and it was super swollen for about 3 months.
View attachment 4971309View attachment 4971311


My surgery was perfect! I woke up in the recovery room feeling thirsty as hell! My throat was so dry, and I had to wait to drink water. The clinic was very nice to provide me with everything I needed for my post-surgery recovery. Their recovery bag included my medications, two ice/heating pads, pumpkin juice, q-tips, petroleum jelly, extra gauze, and a face mask.

Here are some pictures of what's provided in the post-surgery bag.
View attachment 4971333

My post-surgery experience was great! My surgery price included all of my post-op appointments. Dr. Kim always took his time to analyze my nose and answer all of my questions. Joy was attentive and responded to all of my messages right away. I'm not going to lie, after my cast removal, I was depressed for the first three months of my recovery. First of all, my nose bridge and nose tip were extremely high. I couldn't believe it! Dr. Kim had said I didn't need an implant in the first place, so I was shocked when I saw my nose bridge. Secondly, I wasn't aware that I wasn't going to be able to smile for months! The healing process varies from person to person, but I had my surgery on Feb 14th, and I wasn't able to fully smile until the end of April. My smile looked weird for a VERY long time. Lastly, I had a hard time breathing out of my right nostril. Because of those three issues, I kept messaging Joy all day and night, but she was so patient with me. Always responded to all of my questions and concerns nicely and politely.

Here are some pictures showing my bridge now. I think it's nice for those who like high nose bridges, but I don't like it nor do I think it fits my face. The first picture is without makeup and the second picture is with makeup.

View attachment 4971317View attachment 4971318

I am getting close to my one-year mark so here are my final thoughts. Overall, I think Dr. Kim did a good job, but I think he’s done better on other patients. I'll start with the cons. I wish Dr. Kim had narrowed my nose as I asked. I am still insecure about how the left side of my nose bone is wider than the right. I think my results would have been nicer had he performed an osteotomy. The other thing I am not happy with is the height of my bridge. When I reached out to Joy, I learned that Dr. Kim had used a 3mm implant, which explains why my nose bridge is this high. Joy explained that Dr. Kim went with the 3mm implant because he had to shave down a small bump on my nose, but I don't think a 3mm implant was necessary. On a lighter note... the tip of my nose did drop, and it looks beautiful. Also, my nostril breathing issue has gotten better, but it has not been resolved. Dr. Kim did ask me to go see an ENT doctor, but I'm an English teacher who can't request time off during the school year, so I plan to see an ENT doctor this week. I'll end this review with the pros. While it may sound like I'm unhappy, I think the pros outweigh the cons in my opinion. My surgery went well, my post-surgery care was great! The post-surgery communication was magnificent. I would only advise these four things for anyone who plans to have surgery.

1. Do your research! Know exactly what you want… from the procedures to the silicone sizes.

2. Be firm about what you want. I wanted an osteotomy, so I should have made sure I had gotten it.

3. Go to a safe and honest clinic that covers all of your post-surgery appointments and medications. ITEM was amazing in that department. I wasn't worried about shadow doctors or something going wrong with my anesthesia.

4. Know that the recovery process is LONG, but so worth it!

So, would I recommend Dr. Kim? Yes, I would. As I mentioned earlier, aside from my nose bridge being too high and him not narrowing down my nose, everything else was perfect. I was told by someone who just had their surgery at ITEM that Dr. Kim will be moving to his own clinic so please keep that in mind. If you have any questions, feel free to message me or leave a comment below.

Here are some of my most recent pictures: My new nose looks much better, but I would have been a lot more satisfied if the bridge of my nose was lower and my nasal bone was narrowed. I have thick skin, so I don’t think this is the final result. I might update this review if there are any changes. Thanks for reading, and I hope you found this review helpful.

View attachment 4971320View attachment 4971321View attachment 4971323View attachment 4971328



****PS: This isn't a promotional review. I paid for my entire surgery in full and did not receive anything in return.
Hi Soulmate_92, My name is Ralph, and I'm a new member. I like the new nose that you got. In my opinion, the nasal bone could have used some more narrowing jobs. But they're looking great on you. By the way, I have a few questions regarding rhinoplasty surgeons, and I hope you can help me. I'm a male located in the US. I'm trying to locate a good rhino surgeon who's specialized in rhinoplasty in Korea. I've contacted the seouldmedicalguides for leads to the right rhino surgeons. Kris @ the seoulmedicalguides responded to my request and attached a PDF file consisting of 5 clinics that, according to Kris, would be of great choice if I really decide to have my nose fixed by one of them. The list that Kris recommends includes Answer PS, Iron PS, View PS, ID hospital, and JK PS. As far as my research goes, I find many negative reviews about the ID hospital in connection with botched plastic surgeries. That being said, ID hospital is crossed off the list. About the other 4 clinics, I'm considering Dr. Min Choi @ Answer PS. Do you know or hear about this clinic or this doctor by any chance? Someone online wrote that Dr. Min Choi strictly operates 2 surgeries per day to ensure the best outcomes. I'd love to gather as many useful tips as I can before making up my mind on which doctors I should go to. If you have any good rhinoplasty surgeons to recommend, that'd be awesome.
 
Hi Soulmate_92, My name is Ralph, and I'm a new member. I like the new nose that you got. In my opinion, the nasal bone could have used some more narrowing jobs. But they're looking great on you. By the way, I have a few questions regarding rhinoplasty surgeons, and I hope you can help me. I'm a male located in the US. I'm trying to locate a good rhino surgeon who's specialized in rhinoplasty in Korea. I've contacted the seouldmedicalguides for leads to the right rhino surgeons. Kris @ the seoulmedicalguides responded to my request and attached a PDF file consisting of 5 clinics that, according to Kris, would be of great choice if I really decide to have my nose fixed by one of them. The list that Kris recommends includes Answer PS, Iron PS, View PS, ID hospital, and JK PS. As far as my research goes, I find many negative reviews about the ID hospital in connection with botched plastic surgeries. That being said, ID hospital is crossed off the list. About the other 4 clinics, I'm considering Dr. Min Choi @ Answer PS. Do you know or hear about this clinic or this doctor by any chance? Someone online wrote that Dr. Min Choi strictly operates 2 surgeries per day to ensure the best outcomes. I'd love to gather as many useful tips as I can before making up my mind on which doctors I should go to. If you have any good rhinoplasty surgeons to recommend, that'd be awesome.
Hi Ralph,
I agree with you, and that's why I plan to go back and see if Dr. Kim would narrow the nose bone. I hate the idea of going through that recovery process all over again, but I think now is the best time, since I can cover my face with my mask! lol

I personally do not recommend going through SMG for your surgery. They work with specific hospitals, so that alone is biased in my opinion. As you mentioned before, ID had a few botched surgeries. I'm not sure about the other clinics, but I do remember going to JK for my FG consultation and they gave me a crazy high price compared to what some other people paid. I called them out on it so they lowered the price and offered me a model contract. I got a really sketchy vibe from them and decided not to get my surgery there. I don't know much about the other clinics, but the only two doctors I could recommend right now are Dr.Kim from ITEM and Dr. Kim from OPERA. Their work is consistent, they're safe, and they have a wonderful team... which is very important for post-surgery care. Most importantly, both of them try their best to satisfy their clients. Some doctors stop responding/caring the minute they complete your surgery, but they're not like that. They will listen to your concerns and help you find a solution. There's a Kakao chatroom where you could find more info about Answer PS, View PS, and Iron Ps from people who had their surgery at those clinics. PM me if you want to join that chat. Good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ralpphilz
Your nose looks nice! How long would you say it takes for the swelling to go away completely? I heard it can take up to 6 months, is it true?

Hi~
Thank you, and that is correct! I think the deswelling process varies from person to person, but it's safe to say you will have a good idea of what your final results will look like by the 6th/8th month. I started seeing definitions around my nose 3 to 4 months post-surgery.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bananaflan
How long did you do research? I'm so nervous I feel like I might do research forever and never end up doing it!
Btw really like your results!
I researched for about two years. I was originally supposed to have my surgery with Dr. Lee at VIP, but I spoke to a few people who had their nose done by him and ended up changing my mind. I met with a girl who had her nose done with Dr. Kim at ITEM and that's when I knew I wanted to get my surgery done there.

Thank you and I hope you find the perfect surgeon for your surgery. <3
 
Hi~
Thank you, and that is correct! I think the deswelling process varies from person to person, but it's safe to say you will have a good idea of what your final results will look like by the 6th/8th month. I started seeing definitions around my nose 3 to 4 months post-surgery.
I'm at just a little over 1 week now haha. Patiently waiting for my nose to swell down..
 
Hi~
Thank you, and that is correct! I think the deswelling process varies from person to person, but it's safe to say you will have a good idea of what your final results will look like by the 6th/8th month. I started seeing definitions around my nose 3 to 4 months post-surgery.
I'm at just a little over 1 week now haha. Patiently waiting for my nose to swell down..
 
Hello Everyone,

I just wanted to write about my nose job surgery experience at ITEM Clinic with Dr. Kim. Before we get into the review, I'd like to mention the reason I wanted to get my nose done in the first place. Around the age of 14, I became insecure about my nose. I felt like my nose was too wide for my face and thought I would look prettier with a less wide/bulbous nose. My goal was not to change my nose and look like someone else but to enhance my nose so that I'd look like a prettier version of myself. Now, let's get started with the review. In Feb 2020, I consulted with three clinics and decided to get my surgery done at ITEM for numerous reasons.

1. I met with a girl who had gotten her rhinoplasty surgery with Dr. Kim, she had a similar (thick) nose to mine, and her results were beautiful!

2. Dr. Kim made me feel comfortable because he was direct, and he did not rush our consultation. He kept asking me if I had any more questions, and he answered each-and-every one of them.

3. Joy was the most amazing translator I've ever met. She was kind, responsive, and tried her hardest to help me out in any way possible, especially post-surgery, but I'll talk more about that later on.


On the day of my consultation, Dr. Kim and I went over what I wanted. I told him I wanted an alar reduction, tip plasty, silicone implant, and to narrow the overall look of my nose. Dr. Kim had suggested that I didn't need the silicone implant because I already had a defined nose bridge (I didn't realize that until he pointed that out.) I agreed but told him I thought the silicone implant might give my nose more definition, so we agreed to use a small implant. No more than 2/2.5 mm max.

Here are some before pictures: As you can see, I have really thick skin, a wide nose, and flared alar rims.
View attachment 4971306View attachment 4971304View attachment 4971307


My surgery date was on February 14th. I know right, how romantic lol. I met with Joy, did some paperwork, met with Dr. Kim, and we went over the surgery plans once again. As we were going over the plans, I realized we didn't address him narrowing down my nasal bone, so I asked him if he could do so, and he first said he didn't think I needed it and then he said he thought it would be safer to wait and see if I wanted it done after this surgery. Honestly, I had a bad feeling once he said that because I knew that's one thing I wanted to get done because I had a wide nose, so narrowing the nasal bone would've helped with the overall look. I also did NOT want to pay to get my nose done twice, but at that point, it was too late, and I didn't want to second guess him or put pressure on him to do it since he was against it at that moment. So, I went ahead and had the surgery.

Here are some post-surgery pictures: This was on the 7th day when I got my cast removed. My nose was covered with blackheads and it was super swollen for about 3 months.
View attachment 4971309View attachment 4971311


My surgery was perfect! I woke up in the recovery room feeling thirsty as hell! My throat was so dry, and I had to wait to drink water. The clinic was very nice to provide me with everything I needed for my post-surgery recovery. Their recovery bag included my medications, two ice/heating pads, pumpkin juice, q-tips, petroleum jelly, extra gauze, and a face mask.

Here are some pictures of what's provided in the post-surgery bag.
View attachment 4971333

My post-surgery experience was great! My surgery price included all of my post-op appointments. Dr. Kim always took his time to analyze my nose and answer all of my questions. Joy was attentive and responded to all of my messages right away. I'm not going to lie, after my cast removal, I was depressed for the first three months of my recovery. First of all, my nose bridge and nose tip were extremely high. I couldn't believe it! Dr. Kim had said I didn't need an implant in the first place, so I was shocked when I saw my nose bridge. Secondly, I wasn't aware that I wasn't going to be able to smile for months! The healing process varies from person to person, but I had my surgery on Feb 14th, and I wasn't able to fully smile until the end of April. My smile looked weird for a VERY long time. Lastly, I had a hard time breathing out of my right nostril. Because of those three issues, I kept messaging Joy all day and night, but she was so patient with me. Always responded to all of my questions and concerns nicely and politely.

Here are some pictures showing my bridge now. I think it's nice for those who like high nose bridges, but I don't like it nor do I think it fits my face. The first picture is without makeup and the second picture is with makeup.

View attachment 4971317View attachment 4971318

I am getting close to my one-year mark so here are my final thoughts. Overall, I think Dr. Kim did a good job, but I think he’s done better on other patients. I'll start with the cons. I wish Dr. Kim had narrowed my nose as I asked. I am still insecure about how the left side of my nose bone is wider than the right. I think my results would have been nicer had he performed an osteotomy. The other thing I am not happy with is the height of my bridge. When I reached out to Joy, I learned that Dr. Kim had used a 3mm implant, which explains why my nose bridge is this high. Joy explained that Dr. Kim went with the 3mm implant because he had to shave down a small bump on my nose, but I don't think a 3mm implant was necessary. On a lighter note... the tip of my nose did drop, and it looks beautiful. Also, my nostril breathing issue has gotten better, but it has not been resolved. Dr. Kim did ask me to go see an ENT doctor, but I'm an English teacher who can't request time off during the school year, so I plan to see an ENT doctor this week. I'll end this review with the pros. While it may sound like I'm unhappy, I think the pros outweigh the cons in my opinion. My surgery went well, my post-surgery care was great! The post-surgery communication was magnificent. I would only advise these four things for anyone who plans to have surgery.

1. Do your research! Know exactly what you want… from the procedures to the silicone sizes.

2. Be firm about what you want. I wanted an osteotomy, so I should have made sure I had gotten it.

3. Go to a safe and honest clinic that covers all of your post-surgery appointments and medications. ITEM was amazing in that department. I wasn't worried about shadow doctors or something going wrong with my anesthesia.

4. Know that the recovery process is LONG, but so worth it!

So, would I recommend Dr. Kim? Yes, I would. As I mentioned earlier, aside from my nose bridge being too high and him not narrowing down my nose, everything else was perfect. I was told by someone who just had their surgery at ITEM that Dr. Kim will be moving to his own clinic so please keep that in mind. If you have any questions, feel free to message me or leave a comment below.

Here are some of my most recent pictures: My new nose looks much better, but I would have been a lot more satisfied if the bridge of my nose was lower and my nasal bone was narrowed. I have thick skin, so I don’t think this is the final result. I might update this review if there are any changes. Thanks for reading, and I hope you found this review helpful.

View attachment 4971320View attachment 4971321View attachment 4971323View attachment 4971328



****PS: This isn't a promotional review. I paid for my entire surgery in full and did not receive anything in return.
thank you for all this info! If you don't mind me asking, is there a reason you choose not to use rib?
 
Top